Bot or Not?

2/14/2023

Click the image above to read the article in its entirety. Write a Reader's Response to what you read. Be specific and detailed. Refer to quotes or lines from the article. Include how you would define a utopian society.

1. INCLUDE: First Initial, Last Name AND Class Block.

2. Respond in no more than five (5) complete sentences and no less than three (3) complete sentences. (This helps you write more concisely and think more critically.)

3. You MUST comment on at least TWO other posts from any student in any class. Your replies cannot be identical comments on different posts and posting shallow comments such as "I agree" or "I disagree" will earn you a zero. Make sure your reply addresses the comment that you are responding to.

4. Set a weekly alarm or calendar timer. Whatever you do to remember other important events, I'd do the same for this assignment.

5. Don't wait until the last minute. Telling me that you didn't do the assignment on Friday because you broke your leg, for example, on Thursday will not do anything for you when you've had a week. Be responsible and accountable.

CAUTION!! Do NOT embarrass me, yourself, your class, the English department, the school, your family or your upbringing with tasteless, meaningless comments. This is for a grade.

DISCLAIMER: If you do not respond AND comment on TWO others, you will not receive credit for this assignment. If you do not write your name correctly, and I don't see your work, you will not receive credit for this assignment. It's all or nothing.

WARNING: If you post even one second past midnight, your comment might appear to be posted, but as soon as it is opened to be graded, it will automatically delete.

Due Fri., February 17, 2023 11:59 p.m. CST

m.santos 7b

2/14/2023 11:51:24 pm

The controvercy in this article highlights the fear we have about technology not benefiting our education system. I believe that this ChatGPT will be used in a non-beneficial way in our learning path. We have curriculm that challenges us to actually have an opinion for ourselves and to use critical thinking. "why write if a bot does it for me?why learn when a bot does it better?" This high schooler from PACE in texas insinuates the lack of effort overcoming our generation about wanting to actually learn. A utopian society is unrealistic and cannot happen in reality because the citizens are truely free to think independently, have no fear in their world, and living together harmonious. In my eyes it is where things are as good as it should be for the people. This society actually treats their people equally and with dignity but this perfection it sets on things is terrifying to me because how can they live without flaws in their lives?

Saniyah Joubert 7B

2/15/2023 02:03:36 pm

There's nothing wrong with living in a world without flaws. I believe the chatgpt isn't made to challenge us but more assist and make things more similar and help us come to a better understanding. Ask yourself "why walk when we can drive?" Utopian society is real as long as you push a dream into reality. Cars, tall buildings, and advanced technology are all a part of utopian society until they were pushed into reality.

J Melgar 6B link

2/17/2023 11:00:37 am

Although you do make some fair points, many people today continue to advance our technology; there could be a point into where technology becomes too advanced to some or even all, to a point where it does challenge us instead of assisting us. Even today technology is a challenge for people, so continuing to make chats and robots could worsen society.

C Valdez 3A

2/17/2023 11:56:05 am

I agree it's better to use it to assist us than to think of it as a challenge. It's really helpful for students who struggle with homework and learn easier with it and I don't think it's as bad as people think it is. We should want technology to get better as well instead of wanting it not to because people are just paranoid and having better technology is going to be better when they get used to it.

zayla f 2a

2/22/2023 11:11:07 am

I agree , technology makes things easier for us which as been stated . It also helps cover over problems and flaws though . It is mostly used for fun instead of education though . Schools would mostly require a pencil , and a paper , the new generation , ans society just outgrew on
others , It also make things look a certain way it isn't .

J Martinez 3a

2/16/2023 08:58:07 am

I agree but i also think the gpt could help are educational system to because if it shows how to get the answers it could help the students maybe understand more if there teacher didnt explain it well.

Alexia Ruiz 1A

2/16/2023 06:44:29 pm

I think that would be cool but i also think that would benefit very little people. If we're being honest, most kids would just use it to cheat or copy down the work. They wouldn't use it to actually obtain what it was trying to teach. It's what kids already do with their phones and computers.

Zariya B. 1A

2/17/2023 09:37:05 am

I disagree, because this generation of kids are already lazy as it is, thanks to Covid. We don't need a robot to do anything for us. We are capable of anything we put our mind to. Having a robot basically think for us is unnecessary. We should be able to answer questions, write essays, and overall just learn on our own.

S Griffin 3A link

2/16/2023 02:33:41 pm

In my opinion,things aren't always what they seem in technology because it's not as beneficial to some people. When you think about it, Texas isn't a world full of freedom. It can be unrealistic to those who think everything can be independent.

E. Adame 2A

2/16/2023 06:44:50 pm

Flaws are always meant to happen, With this bot I think it can help without taking advantage of what it is really used for. I understand both sides of the story because everyone will have different thoughts about everything. I would say experimenting with it at least is a good way of trying different things because we more than likely will not keep the traditional way of school in the far future

Khamari Caldwell 1A

2/17/2023 11:21:10 am

Experimenting with the bot is a great way to see how it will work with students. Maybe some students will like it or some won't like it, that's a great way to decide if we should use it or not.

Saniyah Joubert 7B

2/15/2023 01:15:22 pm

I believe everything was a utopian society at a point in time. Like cars, humans didn't have them back then, and I bet people thought the idea was completely incorrect in impossible. I believe a utopia society is an idea that sounds unreal, like the chatbot.

K Sheffield 2A

2/17/2023 10:05:36 am

The utopian society is everything that seems unreal i believe that anything is possible and achievable in the world at this point of time

c moore 6b

2/15/2023 04:48:13 pm

i with what shes saying it was made to help us in a way that is similar but also understanding but also sounds unreal but also not as true as you make it out to be like but like even before we didint have the things we have now like cars and other things like that but it does unreal do believe things like chatbot.

J martinez 3a

2/16/2023 08:56:29 am

i agree to this could help us in ways but i also understand that this could hurt are edcuational system but it could also help it theres pros and cons to this .

J Pearl 2A

2/16/2023 03:50:13 pm

I agree ChatGPT can help in ways like all technology but it also has it's own downsides.

J Martinez 3a

2/16/2023 08:54:49 am

The article highlights the fear of this new technolgy because they believe it can hurt our educational system . In the article it states " and robs students of motivation to do there work i this could go both ways but i do understand because kids wont have the same movtivaition to learn and do there work because they can easily get there answers . But when they said this could be the end of the world that very exharated but this gpt could help us get smarter in ways .

Saniyah Joubert 7B

2/16/2023 09:04:05 am

Yeah, like okay it "could end the world," but we can't be afraid of the future. I see the bot as more of a tutor than a calculator or Wikipedia, I believe it would more assist us with a situation and not so much give us the answers.

m.santos 7b

2/16/2023 03:37:01 pm

i agree that it can hurt or affect our education system but we have to take in the fact that the chatbot will be our way of cheating through classes and in life.

J pearl 2A

2/16/2023 03:48:13 pm

I agree that it ribs students of motivation to do there work as I could also make them want to try and use ChatGPT because other students are using it and passing with no consequence.

E. Adame 2A

2/16/2023 06:36:27 pm

I think that most adults and teachers are not accepting the fact that now is different than the past. I agree that it could helps us get smarter if we can use it in the correct way. Knowing that it is already banned in schools without giving a chance to this bot stresses me out that schools are not willing to try new things and keep it traditional.

X. McDonald 7B

2/17/2023 03:45:19 pm

Yea I definitely think that it could help us get smarter I just think the teachers should help us learn how to use it a positive manner and not just to copy answers down.

K Sheffield 2A

2/17/2023 10:00:29 am

Students dont get motivated to do their work anymore because of technology and electronics. They always can look it up instead of learning the information

J Melgar 6B link

2/17/2023 11:00:24 am

I agree. The article also states how this new advanced technology could help students become familiar with technology as it will be a great help to them in the future. It also states how ChatGPT can aid learning. In conclusion there is both positive and negative benefits from ChatGPT

C Valdez 3A

2/17/2023 11:50:31 am

I agree that them saying it could be the end of the world is very exaggerated. There's still ways to stop kids from cheating with it and we shouldn't be scared of it because of that. It's better to have it because students can use it outside of class to study or understand homework easier.

X. McDonald 7B

2/17/2023 03:43:42 pm

Yea saying it could be the end of the word seems pretty overboard I think GPT can help people like an online tutor.

Desiree Ware 3A

2/17/2023 06:19:05 pm

Yes, I agree it does develop fear for teachers in the education systems. Their students could easily cheat from a new advanced device and possibly that could lead to teachers having to deal with the backlash and stress of their students simply not putting in the effort to learn the material the teachers teach them.

K Sheffield 2A

2/16/2023 09:52:26 am

In this article it talks about how technology can hurt or damage or educational system and how we learn because in the article it says "Why learn if the bot does it for me". They basically saying why would we have to learn and do work if the bot or google can give us the information. An utopian society is an society that doesnt exist in real life like its all fake

S Griffin 3A link

2/16/2023 02:18:15 pm

Some things aren't what they seem when it comes to technology because not everything can be true. Even if the internet gives you the answers, you shouldn't assume everything that's right in front of you. It shouldn't be handled for you.

Sydney Griffin link

2/16/2023 02:11:26 pm

This article highlights the anxiety we have for technology because it does not benefit our education. I feel that ChatGPT will not be used in a beneficial way, since they are very brief and often lack the level of knowledge required to write a paper on a certain topic. We have a curriculum that challenges us to have an opinion for ourselves and nobody else. In this society, they actually treat people with respect, which may not seem promising because it may have an effect on other people.

Erik Ramos 6B

2/16/2023 02:49:00 pm

The article about the ChatGPT its crazy about how a powerful new artificial intelligence chatbot. I believe that students having access to chatbot will affect a lot of hard workers students that put all the effort.Especially teacher that dont know about this, wont to be able to help students that actually needs helps.

J pearl 2A

2/16/2023 03:45:46 pm

The article about ChatGPT is very crazy and kind of cool how far technology has come. It also shows how powerful it can be for all the good and wrong reasons. Like it said in the article how are students supposed to learn if the computer does it all for you. It also makes it unfair for people who actually try to get their assignments done unlike the people who use ChatGPT.

Alexia Ruiz 1A

2/16/2023 06:39:16 pm

I agree, it is crazy and cool to see how far technology has come but i think it's also a bit scary and unnatural. I don't think humans were ever meant to be around all this technology. I think we can stand to be without the chatGPT.

eduardo maso

2/17/2023 09:30:56 am

yes and no to your comment. I agree with the fact of how much we have advanced but disagree with the fact that we weren't meant to be with such advanced tech. We evolve and replace

eduardo maso 2a

2/17/2023 09:29:47 am

i agree technology has come a very far way. The fact that jobs and how unfair it is to those who actually try and work for their grade to be classified next to those who just cheat isn't motivational at all to those who do what they're suppose to be doing.

R. Aponte 2A link

2/17/2023 09:48:11 am

Our lives are changing everyday and bots are in our near future. There are good and bad things about it. People may take advantage of our technology and others won't. Adults are against having bots in our schools and students are concerned, but want bots.

A. Hernandez 5B

2/17/2023 09:48:20 am

I agree. our technology is so advanced that you can do anything with it now. There are some goods and bads to it. I feel that technology can be used for a good reason when students need help learning.

Heela A 7B

2/17/2023 02:08:55 pm

I agree with this, it is kind of cool as well. I do think there could be some good use that comes out of ChatGPT. Maybe one that we don't know of yet, not for studying though.

E. Adame 2A

2/16/2023 06:25:23 pm

The main argument for this article is either ¨ Have ChatGPT blocked because it ruins the whole idea of schools, or ¨Using ChatGPT before has been really helpful for me. I think it's the way that teachers and schools are afraid of this new technology that they have no way of stopping. I think it is more adults who are concerned about saying it ruins our motivation or makes us lose our creativity when it helps when the time is needed. I do think that these teachers and adults are trying to not have bad intentions but there can always be ways to go around this. In a similar article someone stated ¨allowing it for some assignments, but not others¨. I do think this is a good idea but I can understand the concerns with this bot thinking we are cheating but we never know the full capabilities if we have never tried it before. I am more of somewhat in the middle because I agree with both sides of the story, but our future is changing whether we accept it or not.

Alexia Ruiz 1A

2/16/2023 06:29:30 pm

After reading this article and seeing the different opinions of students I've formed my own. I don't think the chat box should be allowed in school for a couple of reasons. The first one being we're doing fine without a chat box, the second, it will just lead to the dumbification of society. I think it would prevent people from learning and make them dumb which is exactly what people want for society to be in every dystopian word. In a utopia everyone would be educated and not rely on technology.

F Maltos 3A

2/17/2023 11:22:18 pm

I'm with you on your statement because I also think that they should not allow the ChatGPT in school because you said that we are doing fine without a chat box and that is true since we are using our knowledge and learning without this new technology. I do agree with you when you said that it will lead to the dumbification of society and what if we want to be doctors or lawyers and we wont know anything. We should keep education like this and not rely on technology.

Makyia Lyons 5B link

2/17/2023 08:50:10 am

After reading the article and seeing the different opinions from students it states that to Have ChatGPT blocked because its ruins the whole idea of schools, or Using ChatGPT is helpful for the students, and the teachers don't like it. I feel like the chatbox is overrated. I don't think we need the chatbox because we have been doing good without the chatbox so why now use the chatbox.

R. Aponte 2A link

2/17/2023 09:31:44 am

Bots are good and helpful only if you use it in that way because if you don't it starts to get dangerous and harmful. Many adults don't like it , but several kids are arguing that we should have ChatGPT. Bots are the change in life, and I'm very worried about our future.

A. Hernandez 5B

2/17/2023 09:46:11 am

I agree, bots are programmed with advanced technology. We can learn a lot from these bots and it can really help us with our future. It can also help our teachers instead of making them afraid from our technology.

jkyla dawkins 1a

2/17/2023 12:51:54 pm

i agree, teachers wouldn't know if students are copying of actually doing the work. i think that technology would be our future.

R. Aponte 2A link

2/17/2023 09:21:10 am

When I was reading "What Students Are Saying About ChatGPT," By The Learning Network, I was very concerned about our new advanced technology. It's exciting but very terrifying. Schools are banning Chatbots to be used in their school because they feel like kids will take advantage of the bots. "several teenagers argued that A.I. is the future, and schools should embrace it rather than restrict it." Our future is only getting better and advancing, but it can be dangerous. We are so dependent on our phones just imagine how much we would rely on the bots. It helps us in many ways, but it can also be bad for us.

B Wilkinson 6B

2/17/2023 09:51:19 am

I agree, some things made with ai can become scary such as robots and other things.

R. Beck

2/17/2023 09:27:46 am

As stated "How will teachers be able to know for sure that their students are actually learning what they think they are or is it just a robot doing their work for them?" This is a fact because if the A.I. is as good as it is being advertised no one will ever do there own work and they will be shorted of their education. On the flip side "It could be a good inspiration tool for students who lack ideas for an essay" and an help kids that may not be as easily enthused or come on to writiong a hard as others.

Kimberly Yanez 3a

2/17/2023 10:05:03 am

I agree with this , how will teachers really know students are really doing their work or just copying.This new technology can really replace someones knowledge and cause people to just rely on it.

Desiree ware 3A

2/17/2023 06:16:04 pm

Yes, I agree because why would students go out of their way to do their work, when they have a device that will do their work under 5 minutes. It just in general would cause students to lose motivation and become lazy down the road.

eduardo maso 2a

2/17/2023 09:28:17 am

as someone who used chatgtp i agree. The idea that students will lose motivation to do their work is very much plausible. Why would you do work if you have an ai doing it for you i mean aren't they programmed to always be more precise than us? Its true the site is dangerous for us teens because we need to learn we need to ask for us to understand and not rely on any other source that isn't school related such as our teachers who work hard to teach and learn the material.

B Wilkinson 6B

2/17/2023 09:50:32 am

I agree with the part where you said if ai can do it why would a student do the work. AI can sometimes be far more intelligent than humans.

R. Waits 7B

2/17/2023 12:43:04 pm

This is very interesting because you have actually used the ChatGTP and still picked the latter option. While I agree that the AI is built to be intelligently correct, more than humans, it is incredibly dangerous. The use of an AI is widely encouraged by many, but we're sacrificing the older days when we learned everything by hand. That is how we were able to create and build today.

A. Hernandez 5B

2/17/2023 09:40:19 am

When I was reading "What Students Are Saying About ChatGPT," By The Learning Network, I was very concerned about our new advanced technology. Our technology keeps getting better an better every year. I believe that technology is our future.

B Wilkinson 6B

2/17/2023 09:49:35 am

This article is talking about how school districts and people are reacting to the ChatGPT AI. As a person who has used ChatGPT it is truly and remarkable thing that us humans have been able to create.And people should start utilizing it instead of trying to ban it from schools. I say this because it can, for example, write small amounts of code, write essays, and it can write a sonnet about admission to Harvard as the girl Shekina said in the article as she was talking about ChatGPT.

A.Tindle 7b

2/17/2023 03:08:48 pm

This is why I couldnt chose if I think Chatbots should be used in schools, because I agree that it could help to some extent, but could also be damaging. Chatbots could make people use their brain less, making them less intelligent.

Kimberly Yanez 3A

2/17/2023 10:03:15 am

In the article about chatGPT I learned a new form of technology I would've never thought would be realistic, it never came to me that something so advanced would be real.In the article it gives different peoples perspectives of how they see the chatGPT, some are great and some are not so awesome but my thoughts on the chatGPT is that it seems useful but I don't think it should be allowed in schools due to students would rely on it and have it there to do all work,"The teacher is way more reliable than any internet source. ChatGPT can be helpful when you’re outside of school, on weekends and/or on summer break". This reaction to the bot really got to me and agreed with it because yes technology can be good but its not amazing to be relying on technology and stuff should be learned through hand to and from books.I think it would be used in a lazy matter and not for its purposes like being extra help, and tutoring.Outside of school when there's no teachers you dont really have as much help it would be helpful to get people engaged with work or have help outside of school.

R. Waits 7B

2/17/2023 12:37:45 pm

I see what you mean because instead of just cheating. It is easier and more effiecent to use the chat bot to enhance your ability to learn. Especially the areas you talk about concerning "on the weekends.." and that you agreed on the ChatGPT being useful but an actual book than lazing around.

Shamarian Samuels

2/17/2023 10:20:17 pm

I Agree with you although technology is great , a number 2 pencil and a textbook is just as great maybe even better. When you type a question in your phone it automatically give you a direct answer , when your scrolling through a text book trying to find a answer your reading throughout the passage and taking the information in

J Melgar 6B link

2/17/2023 11:00:29 am

From what I got, this article was about advanced technology, being more specific they were talking ChatGPT. In this article they have different points of view. They were some students who believed that ChatGPT was good to use as it helped them with school work and would help them in the future as technology continues to advance. Others believe it wouldn't help as it would put people at a disadvantage from learning and doing things on their own. Some people just believed it was too much technology and were afraid that it would somehow take over. To me I would define utopian as a society that is content, healthy, kind, peaceful and a pleace were technology isn't taking over people.

Cedric lott 2A

2/17/2023 12:35:15 pm

I agree, with fact that utopian society is at peace because look at how much time and effort you have to put in, none at all. Also, I feel like the future with these things would create bad habits that we as humans wouldn't be able to control and it would become widespread. I just think this specific technology tool would be taken out of proportion and used as a disadvantage to maneuver around situations faster.

jkyla dawkins 1a

2/17/2023 12:49:24 pm

i agree, there would be less work for us to do and it eliminates the whole purpose for teachers.

F Maltos 3A

2/17/2023 11:07:47 pm

I understand where you are coming from because in this article different people were talking about how it would help them if the ChatGPT would benefit them in school or not. Some students said it would help them with school, work or if the teacher was not teaching. On the contrary many students said that they will not learn anything with the robot and will take over students knowledge.

Khamari Caldwell 1A

2/17/2023 11:15:47 am

These bots will be helpful to many students across the world. It makes doing classwork in class easier to do. Students won't have to be stressed on how to do work or needing help when they are in class because the bot will provide the answer for them.I believe this new form of technology will be the future of education for many years to come because students already use it help get answers quicker most of the time. This bot will be a great edition to education in my opinion.

Cedric lott 2A

2/17/2023 12:25:15 pm

I agree, because why have to do all that hard work just to get an answer that could have been given to you. It would definitely decrease the amount of time spent on work. Students would recommend this tool because of the stress level also.

C Valdez 6B

2/17/2023 11:42:05 am

The article talks about students' opinion of ChatGPT and there's a lot of negative talk about how it'll make students rely too much on it or make cheating easier, and students less creative. The article also talks about how it's a good thing and that people are exaggerating.

c moore 6b

2/17/2023 11:46:48 am

i believe that the article mainly talks about how pepole feel about bot and how it relate to the things that are going on now and how it sounds more unreal but also not as true as you make it out to be like but like even before we didint have the things we have now like cars and other things like that but it does unreal do believe things like chatbot.

Cedric lott 2A

2/17/2023 12:21:02 pm

I envision that if we were to use this to help and correct us at times we wouldn't be learning anything due to the fact that your not using your brain. I just dont feel as if this is the best option for schools cause of the things it could do. Also, it would just effect all students mentally.

K Lake 3A

2/17/2023 01:02:30 pm

Yeah, like all the tools we need to use in the real world would be an irrelevance such as critical thinking and creativity. This Bot is literally taking that away and those skills that we need to be successful in the future.

A.Tindle 7b

2/17/2023 03:04:32 pm

I feel this way to, when it comes to using your brain. Having all answers given to us, would make us lose reaserch skills, and being able to think on your own. No doubt though, that this Chatbot could help as well, but you have to think do the disadvantages outweigh the advantages.

R. Waits 7B

2/17/2023 12:30:21 pm

The entire article is conversing the possibilities and chances that the ChatGPT might take over the intelligence of regular humans. Although, sometimes the information is not correct, people still take that chance to cheat and copy whatever the bot says.Teenagers around the world were invited to give their opinions on the subject, and I think it was great that they did that because students say the truth no matter the situation,

K Lake 3A

2/17/2023 01:07:21 pm

I do like how they allowed students to give their opinion on the matter rather than just adult talking, as much news like this turns out. But, I do still agree that the possibility of the students just going to the app to do whatever they need to get done in school is still high. And, prevents students from using their heads to do the work and the material.

G.Ojeh B6

2/17/2023 10:42:34 pm

I was considering how the chatgpt would take over human culture as I read the story. They are doing the most of it, so if this were employed to aid us, there really wouldn't be anything to do. The government merely created the illusion that we would be safer while the utopian society doesn't actually exist.

jkyla dawkins 1a

2/17/2023 12:45:45 pm

when i read the article i was thinking about how the chatgpt might take over the human society.if this was used to help us there really wouldnt be anything to do because they're doing most of it.the utopian society really dosen't exsist its just the government made it to seem like we would be more safe.

K Lake 3A

2/17/2023 12:59:16 pm

I understand what the teachers are saying about the Bot. Like, the whole reason for going to school to learn about the material that the teacher is teaching. And, the bot prevents students from actually thinking and using the material. If they were to actually add this in schools, you mind as well just take out all the teachers in the school because they'll just go to the bot for answers and teaching and not the teacher itself.

Heela A 7B

2/17/2023 02:00:14 pm

I agree with this, even the teachers might go to the bots for help

A Heela 7B

2/17/2023 01:10:11 pm

The idea of CHATGPT is very cool but has some flaws. Although it would be nice to have this artificial intelligence that could benefit us and help understand our work, I believe this could also be harmful to our society if not properly used. Maybe in other generations it would be useful, but our generation gen z has already been influenced heavily by social media everyday. Being able to look up any question on google and receive many feedback, or even websites that solve your math problems. CHATGPT would make it worse for students to actually learn the material and gain knowledge since it would do all the work for us. Many people would take advantage of it I feel, and completely give up on their work as a whole. I don't believe a school setting is the proper place to input these new advanced AI's in.

G. Calderon Batista 2A

2/17/2023 10:21:55 pm

I loved the way you worded this because i completely agree with you. We as a generation are already so heavily influenced by technology that brings an A.I would just consume us. We used to just do work on paper then covid hit and we mostly just do work on computers. we look at technology for at least half of the day. i think it wold do more harm than good.

A. Tindle 7b

2/17/2023 02:24:06 pm

In this article, it talks about the ChatGPT. This Chatbot is supposed to expand education with technology. Teenagers give their opinions on whether they think this Chatbot is essential to education. I personally feel like the Chatbot could be useful, but also has its flaws, so you could say im in the middle on this. Like said in the article, the Chatbot could make somone lose creativity, but then some students say they love it, and it helps those who lack knowledge with essays.

R. Brown 7B

2/17/2023 09:37:14 pm

I see your stance on this situation. I can semi understand it because the device is helping a lot of student who might lack in certain educational departments. However, it does make people less creative when the rely on it too often.

G. Calderon Batista 2A

2/17/2023 10:14:31 pm

I think that it can be useful but i agree with you saying it has many flaws. I feel like they still have a lot of work to do before they let schools actually use it properly in a productive way.

Shamarian Samuels

2/17/2023 10:17:11 pm

I agree it’s a blessing and it’s a curse it can positively help students but it can also cause students to become lazy and depend on the machine to think for them.

X. McDonald 7B

2/17/2023 02:37:31 pm

Chat GPT is definitely not the end of the world, but I do think it is kind of scary. I believe teachers should show kids how to use and not abuse chat GPT because it can be helpful. I don't believe that chat GPT makes education useless because people should learn about all categories of education themselves.

R. Brown 3A

2/17/2023 09:20:46 pm

The fact that we are able to use the A.I. in the first place means that it's not a threat. The A.I. are not helpful to students because teachers already teach us so the A.I. is not needed. A.I's are made to make life easier for humans, and like all good things too much of it makes it bad. If we make an A.Is for every problem humans will become lazy. Have you ever seen wall-E its a great movie and an example of what we shouldn't become in more ways than one. (^---^)

Leonardo 1A

2/17/2023 03:06:50 pm

Lately, A.I. has been around everywhere, causing major negativities when it comes to the internet nowdays, so this was to be expected at least. Sometimes, the concepts, and the purposes of certain versions of A.I. can be very cool, but most times, not so much. I may not know much, but other than being able to generate large amounts of text, I cannot really see much of a use other than being used for certain things on the internet to further imrpove specific things. But, if the bot would rob them of motivation, then it should not be used, because when it comes to school work and other things necessary, motivation is the most important thing. If we were all unmotivated in school, where would we be now?

R. Brown 3A

2/17/2023 09:08:53 pm

It is my belief that A.I's are not good nor bad, they are mere advanced programs. They do what they are designed to do and we have no way of removing them even if they help students cheat. They will always be there so the best we could do is explain to students that their grades are important, but at the end of the day if you can't look back and say what you learned then you have wasted your and your teachers time.

G.OjehB6

2/17/2023 10:38:40 pm

This was at least expected because A.I. has recently been making headlines everywhere and seriously harming the internet today. Thoughts and goals behind some A.I. versions can occasionally be very interesting, this is not always the case. I may not know much, but aside from the ability to produce vast amounts of text, I don't really see much of a use for it besides being utilized online to improve various things. But, it shouldn't be used if the bot would sap their motivation because, when it comes to schoolwork and other vital tasks, motivation is the most crucial factor. Where would we be in class if none of us were motivated?

Desiree Ware 3A

2/17/2023 06:13:06 pm

After reading this article about ChatGpt which is a device used to advance education I don't think it should be used in school's or given to students to use. The Chatgpt is a bot used to help students with their work and answer questions. Sometimes the bot can be too smart in giving information to students and end up being a cheat code and easier way for students to cheat, which leads to lower motivation to do any schoolwork at all. As said in the article by Sergio from Glenbard West High School," Essentially the program is a cheat code for writing essays because all you have to do is insert a scenario and it will write for you." Honestly this chat bot could be included when describing a utopian society a imaginary community possessing desirable perfect qualities. It's designed to act as a "perfect"helper to students but in reality has some mistakes as said by students from different schools in the article. A chat bot should not be in school systems.

R. Brown 3A

2/17/2023 08:56:18 pm

This article is about the possibility of students using A.I. technology to write their essays. This to me is a dumb problem for 2 reasons. The first one is technology is made to be used so trying to stop people for using it is dumb. The second reason is that students relying on technology to do school assignments will only dampen their learning and that will make their future filled with many issues. School is meant for learning, that's its only purpose so for students to value their grade on an assignment more than actually learning something is dumb. Having good grades leads you to a river while learning leads you to the ocean.

R. Brown 7B

2/17/2023 09:35:18 pm

I definitely see where you’re coming from. Like students relying on this device will stunt their own personal growth in the basic skill you learn. For example writing and so much more.

R. Brown 7B

2/17/2023 09:33:51 pm

This article is about students using a device called chatGpt. In my opinion I believe that schools should restrict this from their schools. It does not help students grow in fact it actually deters them from learning and knowing the things they need to know. For example some students use it to write their essays. Now if everyone does that their ability to improve their writing skills is very limited. This device stops students from growing on basic skills like writing an so much more so I think that is negatively impacting student which will cause that to also negatively impact our future as well,

G. Calderon Batista 2A

2/17/2023 10:10:38 pm

This article is about A.I Chatgpt that can be used to help students on their work & in the different article highlights it explains how different people have used it & their opinions on it. I personally think something like this would not benefit the educational system because students are going to be cheating & not actually learning. Like what is the point of a teacher ? if we have an A.I bot. I feel like if we developed it more so it could be used in a more productive way then i would be all for it.

Rangel j 6b

2/22/2023 09:17:28 am

yes i agree the students will be cheating instead of learning. THey wont give it their all because they know at the end of the day they have that bot there for them. I dont see good in it in my oppinon it just teaches us to be incapable of stuff we really can do.

Shamarian Samuels

2/17/2023 10:15:27 pm

The controversy in this article shines light on the fear we have about technology that I won’t benefiting to our education system. The Chatgpt is a bot used to help students with their work and answer questions. although it’s a great invention it student’s will look at it as a cheat code.

G. Ojeh B.6

2/17/2023 10:32:22 pm

Living in a perfect world is not bad in any way. I think the chatgpt is more intended to help and make things more comparable so that we can better understand each other rather than to test us. Why walk when we can drive, you could ask. As long as you work to make a dream a reality, a utopian society can exist. Prior to being forced into reality, automobiles, large buildings, and cutting-edge technology were all features of utopian societies.

F Maltos 3A

2/17/2023 10:57:08 pm

In this article I learned how there is a robot that is called ChatGPT and it helps you to write essays and to solve problem sets. In my opinion, I do not think a robot should be in a school environment because it will lack students motivation to learn and would affect students in their education to be successful. Students will not learn and teachers will not be able to know if they are cheating or if they are using their knowledge. In the article it says I would rely too much on these tools and lose the capacity for critical and creative thought, that explains my reason as an why students will not be able to gain more knowledge in school and will affect their education. How I would define an utopian society is that it will not benefit in the future generations because students will have lack of knowledge since a robot will be teaching them more than an actual teacher.

rangel j 6b

2/22/2023 09:15:38 am

yes i agree i dont think they should put the bot inschool because it will lack motivation. it will teach the students to not do anything for themselves. They wont even know how to write their own essay.

Rangel j 6b

2/22/2023 09:12:14 am

After reading this article about this device used to advance education. I dont think it is a good idea to put in schools or be used to help students because all its doing is giving students a way to cheat and if they really have a question its not the same as asking your teacher. They cant show you the same emotion as your teacher. it doesnt teach the students anything just like how it says you enter a scenerio into the bot and it will write an essay foryou. This world is coming to where nobod does anything for themselves anymore.It may be called the "perfect" helper but in reality it has a lot of flaws.

zayla foley 2a

2/22/2023 11:13:44 am

This could be sometimes depending on situation , also covid - 19 made many things change and many people lazy all around the world , and mostly in school . Students can collaborate on group projects using technology-based tools such as wikis and Google docs. The walls of the classrooms are no longer a barrier as technology enables new ways of learning, communicating, and working collaboratively. Technology has also begun to change the roles of teachers and learners.

keira depippo

2/22/2023 12:16:09 pm

i believe that this article is not a good idea to put in schools or be used to to help students because its not the proper type of education it doesnt teach students anything just like how it says you enter a scenerio into the bot and it will write an essay for you .

Comments are closed.

Mixed Ink

Mixed Ink is our class blog, the window into our souls. It was designed to improve students' writing, critical thinking and communication skills by giving them a platform to provide meaningful content based on their interpretation of what they see.

Although the students receive a grade based on a rubric for completing this assignment, they are not graded on complexity of thought. This is a place where students of all levels can freely, confidently and creatively express themselves and their opinions in a nonjudgmental platform. They are required to respond to and critique each other, but degradation, slander, lewdness, etc., will not be tolerated.

Bridge Builders

All subjects are vital to learning, but English is the bridge of communication. So let's build the arch, one word at a time...

Grading Rubric

Learning Objectives

Communicate effectively
Be aware of current events
Write concisely
Boost critical thinking skills
Be accountable
Follow directions
Have a voice about what goes on in the world around you

Bot or Not?

Mixed Ink

Bridge Builders

Grading Rubric

Archives

Categories