DEI or DIE

1/28/2025

Image: OKA Blog

Retailers across the U.S. are cutting DEI initiatives due to political pressure, with Target and Walmart being two of the biggest names. Target’s decision was especially surprising since they had just promoted their commitment to diversity before the election.

A few weeks ago, influencer and entrepreneur Tabitha Brown urged people not to boycott Target entirely. Instead, she encouraged them to shop there but only buy from Black-owned brands. Her concern? A full boycott could hurt small Black-owned businesses that rely on Target to reach more customers.

But some of her followers disagreed, calling her stance selfish. They argue that corporations like Target and Walmart still profit from consumers of color, making selective shopping ineffective. Others believe boycotts work best when they completely disrupt the system—just like the Montgomery Bus Boycott during the Civil Rights Movement. Their actions weren’t about finding convenient middle grounds; they were about collective, often uncomfortable disruption to demand change. A bold, unified stand can force companies to change, but it often comes at a cost.

It's hard for some to know the right move. Consumers have to consider whether the short-term sacrifices of a boycott outweigh the potential long-term gains. And if change requires disruption, how do consumers make the Targets, Walmarts, and Amazons of the world feel the pressure without giving in to convenience?

Notes to help inform your opinions:

What is DEI?

Diversity is embracing the differences everyone brings to the table, whether those are someone’s race, age, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexual orientation, physical ability or other aspects of social identity.
Equity is treating everyone fairly and providing equal opportunities.
Inclusion is respecting everyone’s voice and creating a culture in which people from all backgrounds feel encouraged to express their ideas and perspectives.

Let’s Write!: Thoughts?

INSTRUCTIONS

1. INCLUDE: Last Name, First Initial, AND Class Block. You do not have to include an email address or a website.

2. Respond to the post. Read the entire post, including watching any videos or reading any articles attached. Do not post vague or ambiguous commentary. Your post should have depth, be thoughtful, and provide specific, meaningful insight. Make sure it addresses the topic and encourages reflection, discussion, or a connection.

3. You MUST comment on at least TWO other posts from any student in any class. Your replies cannot be identical comments on different posts and posting shallow comments such as "I agree" or "I disagree" will earn you a zero. Make sure your reply addresses the comment that you are responding to.

4. Language. Do NOT use profanity. Vague or repeated responses will not be accepted in your post or replies.

5. Disrespectful comments will not be accepted and will result in a zero whether you do the assignment or not.

REMINDERS

**Set a weekly alarm or calendar timer. Whatever you do to remember other important events, I'd do the same for this assignment.

**Don't wait until the last minute. Telling me that you didn't do the assignment on Friday because you broke your leg, for example, on Thursday will not do anything for you when you've had a week. Be responsible and accountable.

**How to post. Click in the top right hand corner or the lower left hand corner where it says Comments to access the discussion board. Once there, scroll to the bottom of the page to post a Reply. After, choose comments from at least two students from any class and Reply to what they wrote.

CAUTION!! Do NOT embarrass me, yourself, your class, the English department, the school, your family or your upbringing with tasteless, meaningless comments. This is for a grade.

DISCLAIMER: If you do not respond AND comment on TWO others, you will not receive credit for this assignment. If you do not write your name correctly, and I don't see your work, you will not receive credit for this assignment. If you use profanity, you will not receive credit for the work. It's all or nothing.

WARNING: If you post even one second past midnight, your comment might appear to be posted, but as soon as it is opened to be graded, it will automatically delete.

Due Fri., February 9, 11:59 p.m. CST

Bronson M, 3A

2/6/2025 10:45:06 am

My thoughts on companies like Target and Walmart saying they are for DEI but then go against what it stands for is unequal. People should boycott but the idea of buying from only the black-owned business is intelligent. Everyone has to work together to prove a point to companies such as Target.

rivera d 4a

2/6/2025 11:08:30 am

I totally agree, its frustrating when companies say they support DEI but don't follow through. Supporting black owned business while boycotting other products is a smart way to make a statement witout hurting small brands.

Divine Ojeh 3A

2/6/2025 01:32:54 pm

I agree, doing those things is a bright way to make a declaration without harming small brands.

Alexandra W

2/7/2025 08:54:21 am

that the DEI need to follow through what the say some of black-Owneds do need help with there buissnse and it don't help when that DEI don't want to help black- Owneds

Knowles K 1A

2/8/2025 12:06:17 am

Exactly you cant say you support blacked owned businesses and turn around and don’t support them.

Sanchez A 3A

2/6/2025 11:15:07 am

Yea it's funny how they say they are for DEI but do something completely different. The idea of only buying black specific items is kinda selfish on her side, there has to be a better way to push this movement.

Nathan T 3A

2/6/2025 12:39:44 pm

I agree with buying from black owned businesses but not from Walmart or target since they would still end up getting a cut of what they sell.

Esquivel. E 1A

2/6/2025 01:57:24 pm

Yes, the key word is everyone!

Echeverria D 6B

2/6/2025 02:13:31 pm

This method conveys the message of accountability while uplifting minority-owned brands. Together, we can encourage companies to keep their diversity and inclusion promises.

Hernandez M, 4A

2/6/2025 02:59:45 pm

I agree but I also think boycotting all together would be the better choice.

Luster J 3A

2/7/2025 08:30:38 am

Yes I agree that everyone has to work together in order to prove a point to companies. If only a few people try to boycott Target it won't have any effect on them.

Johnson C 8B

2/7/2025 02:49:10 pm

I agree, doing those things is a bright way to make a declaration without harming small brands.

Malvaez M, 1A

2/7/2025 03:02:54 pm

Even though companies supported DEI time ago, it is a shame they no longer do, but it is our job as a community to get our message across to prove something to non supportive DEI companies.

rivera d 4a

2/6/2025 11:05:47 am

The debate about boycotting Target shows how hard it is to take a stand without hurting people. maybe a smarter move is to shop from different brands while still pushing target to keep its DEI promises. that way people can make a difference without harming anyone.

Sanchez A 3A

2/6/2025 11:12:10 am

I agree people should move to a different shopping center to help push the DEI movement. We can't have a movement without one of the sides being impacted.

Stevenson J, 4A link

2/6/2025 02:39:29 pm

I agree several companies have made public announcements that they are moving on from DEI. The reasons given are the realization that hiring or promoting based on race and gender does not produce the best candidates for the position.

Bronson M, 3A

2/6/2025 11:18:56 am

I agree, boycotting Target debate shows how hard it is to start a movement without hurting people. It is smarter to shop from other brands but Target did lie about the DEI promises so we want to prove a point. People can make a difference without harming anyone when supporting black-owned business at stores such as Target and Walmart.

Echeverria D 6B

2/6/2025 02:10:28 pm

I understand your viewpoint. The debate about boycotting Target shows the difficulty of starting a movement without causing harm. It’s better to shop from various brands while holding companies accountable for their DEI promises. Supporting Black-owned businesses in stores like Target and Walmart is a positive way to make a difference. This method conveys the message of accountability while uplifting minority-owned brands. Together, we can encourage companies to keep their diversity and inclusion promises.

Nathan T 3A

2/6/2025 12:41:27 pm

It will be hard boycotting Target and Walmart for those who actually depend from those big brands but if those brands dont support you then why support them

Grant Z 4A

2/6/2025 03:37:28 pm

Ture it would be hard and a lot of work due to them having almost everything we need to make a living.

Divine Ojeh 3A

2/6/2025 01:29:39 pm

I agree, the best approach is to shop from different brands while still pushing target to keep its DEI promises. Its an win win on both ends without causing any harm.

Alarcon A 3A

2/7/2025 08:49:26 am

I agree we should bring more attention to companies who do keep their DEI promise and reject the ones who dont.

Esquivel. E 1A

2/6/2025 01:58:32 pm

I like this idea! We should completely shun these companies and replace them with others that keep their DEI promises.

Knowles K 1A

2/8/2025 12:08:33 am

Agree companies that come out and claim they support black owned businesses but in reality they don’t they should not get a dime from us due to their lack of trust

Hernandez M, 4A

2/6/2025 03:01:50 pm

I agree this would be the best because not only would it be boycotting but it would also make our stance even louder and keep on pushing these stores to keep their DEI promises.

Teniente J. 1A

2/6/2025 06:25:35 pm

True, a peace movement is way better than a violent movement since its better to gather everyone without a risk of getting hurt or dying for both side.

Johnson C 8B

2/7/2025 02:49:35 pm

The reasons given are the realization that hiring or promoting based on race and gender does not produce the best candidates for the position

Renteria R. Anthony 4A

2/7/2025 08:51:47 pm

I agree. Boycotting a large company like Target can have unintended consequences, especially for those who rely on its accessibility or affordability. A more thoughtful approach could be to shop from alternative brands while still holding Target accountable for its DEI promises. By doing so, people can continue to make a statement without causing harm to employees or those who depend on these stores. It’s a way to push for change while still considering the broader impact on the community and individuals who might be affected by a boycott.

Sanchez A 3A

2/6/2025 11:07:04 am

There are so many other brands where people can shop at that doesn't involve big companies like Target and Walmart I never shop at Target and I barely go to Walmart, if boycotting them both is gonna make a change they should do what they want. I am going to do what I want.

rivera d 4a

2/6/2025 11:10:59 am

you are right. there are other of places to shop besides target and Walmart. boycotting is a personal decision and people should do what makes sense for them. if enough people take action it might force these companues to change.

Bronson M, 3A

2/6/2025 11:23:11 am

I agree, many brands support DEI proudly unlike Target and Walmart. I shop at both big companies but I shop at many other stores also. Boycotting can make a change but at the same time you can shop where you want.

Torres. C 3/A

2/6/2025 12:30:08 pm

That is true, at the end of the day we should all be able to shop where we want to dispite the support of the DEI

Grant Z 4A

2/6/2025 03:36:30 pm

I agree we should shop where we want, however consider the fact that they don't want or care about others of different raceses.

Torres. C 3/A

2/6/2025 12:31:02 pm

I can respect the fact that by the end of the day, you will continue to shop where you want despite public opinion.

Kendell D HURRINGTON 4A

2/6/2025 02:54:52 pm

This is definitely the right step forward. We need to start shopping from small businesses and stores. Buying street tacos or going to the open marts to get vegetables. a "Comfortable Life" is still able to be maintained by going just a few miles farther and paying a few dollars more for your needs. It wont be forever, just Until the stores get their acts together.

Teniente J. 1A

2/6/2025 06:24:21 pm

True, there is many other options to shop at, plus those stores may do way better overall than the big companies that they provide. The boycott will just be an effect that will last for awhile but not forever.

Malvaez M, 1A

2/7/2025 03:06:02 pm

This a good solution to get our message across on DEI. Shopping at small businesses can still provide us with everything we would normally get at Walmart or Target. We would be getting our message across by boycotting companies who do not support DEI and will be supporting small businesses too.

Gonzalez D. 1A

2/7/2025 07:51:33 pm

Yes I agree with you, there is many other stores we can shop at that aren’t Walmart or Target.

Jahlil Hawkins 4A

2/6/2025 03:37:42 pm

I agree because just boycotting not going to do anything U can just go to family dollar or Dollar tree

Luster J 3A

2/7/2025 08:33:10 am

Doing what you want is a good way to go about it but it could also cause problems. While it's good you don't already shop there if you turn your back to problems like this it''ll come back and bite you. Especially if your a person of color

Alarcon A 3A

2/7/2025 08:48:05 am

I agree, boycotting is a personal decision, and we should be able to choose whether we want to boycott or not.

Gonzalez S 4A link

2/7/2025 11:29:42 pm

I agree, people are allowed to shop wherever they want to and boycott if they want to It's not a forced action.

Miles D 4A

2/7/2025 11:57:11 pm

I think its not a matter of people doing what they want but its people making those decisions based off of their own situations and what readily available to them.

Torres. C 3/A

2/6/2025 12:28:29 pm

It is completely smart but completely immoral that big brand names are giving ideas to consumers to not only persue them into the purchase of their products but also targeting them due to their financial situations. By making specific products a certain price range for certain audience. And by claiming that they are all about DEI, is a smart move on their end, to falsely give hope to consumers.

Guzman X 6B

2/6/2025 07:06:26 pm

It’s true that big brands often target certain groups with pricing strategies, which can feel manipulative. Claiming to support DEI without actually following through can mislead consumers. Companies often care more about profits than real change. Consumers need to stay aware and hold them accountable.

Smith R 8B

2/6/2025 09:55:45 pm

It was definitely manipulative on Target's part & I'm sure blindsided everyone else as much as it did us. To backtrack on their moral values & to get rid of DEI programs may feel as a big stab in the back to these black-owned businesses in their store, I would not be surprised if some decide to pull their products off their shelf, but I also find it very unlikely.

Hayes T 8B

2/7/2025 09:17:39 pm

I agree with you I feel like target has backstabbed us and they shouldn’t have said they was gonna get rid of DEI

Colocho J 6B

2/7/2025 10:19:04 am

There are many complex arguments and many different perspectives on this issue.

Nathan Torres 3A

2/6/2025 12:37:27 pm

I believe boycotting the brands that do not support the DEI deserve to get boycott. Do the big brands not acknowledge that most of their purchases come from a diversity of customers... Boycotting will have an effect since they will soon realize that they have made a mistake and they would want to switch sides again.

Kendell D HURRINGTON 4A

2/6/2025 02:49:30 pm

They most certainly know who their consumer base is. They simply believe that those in poorer communities don't have the resolve to strike back and harm them.

Divine Ojeh 3A

2/6/2025 01:28:30 pm

This is a tough issue because both sides make goodpoints. A full boycott can be powerful, like the Montgomery Bus Boycott, but it could also hurt the small business that rely on big stores like Target. On the other hand, shopping only from Black owned brands inside Target might help those businesses, but it may not be enough to push the company to bring back its diversity programs.

I think a good approach might be to do a mix of both supporting Black owned businesses outside of big retailers while also putting pressure on companies through boycotts or other actions.

Lopez M 1A

2/7/2025 09:14:53 am

That seems like a good mix between boycotting big retailers while still supporting black-owned businesses. But if we also want to completely boycott these big companies black-owned businesses should find other companies that will support them and help them thrive while leaving companies such as Target and Walmart.

Flores A 4A

2/7/2025 11:18:47 am

this is a hard topic because sure we can have a nation wide boycott but at same time there not to many available alternatives that people know and it can hurt black owned businesses. Plus most people are just going to continue buying from them.

Esquivel. E 1A

2/6/2025 01:56:14 pm

Consumers can selectively buy from black businesses, it is a good idea. But if we truly want to make these big companies feel the pressure we should just stop going to them all together. Black businesses should stop partnering with these companies and find new ways to sell their products freely. It isn't a realistic idea especially because these places are so convenient, but it is an effective idea.

Stevenson J, 4A link

2/6/2025 02:37:16 pm

I agree why can't all these black own businesses that are in these stores like target get together and create their own distribution source?

Jahlil Hawkins 4A

2/6/2025 03:31:04 pm

I agree because if u approach right it could be a mix black businesses

Colocho J 6B

2/7/2025 10:19:53 am

Consumers shaping the business world is effective for a tool change, its not always a realistic or sustainable solution.

Rodriguez R. 4A

2/7/2025 12:47:16 pm

I agree, they should find an alternative store and instead buy the products there too.

Victorino H 8B

2/7/2025 11:51:17 pm

I agree as these companies have no power unless the consumer allows it, however it would also be difficult for the black businesses because they might have to spend more on their business than if they just went to target.

Echeverria D 6B

2/6/2025 02:05:23 pm

The debate over boycotting Target and Walmart due to their decisions to cut DEI Shopping from various brands while urging to uphold its DEI commitments can help make a difference without causing harm. Using selective shopping strategies lets consumers send a message effectively.

Guzman X 6B

2/6/2025 07:04:53 pm

Selective shopping lets people support their values without hurting smaller businesses. It’s a way to send a message while still shopping at big stores. But some might feel that a full boycott would be more powerful. It’s about finding the best way to make a difference.

Alanis A, 3A

2/7/2025 11:23:02 pm

A total stop might be hard for some people, but choosing which items to buy can help them participate over a long time. This way makes sure that companies feel the financial effects while also focusing on helping underrepresented communities

Stevenson J, 4A link

2/6/2025 02:35:03 pm

DEI stands for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, which we define as follows: Diversity is the presence of differences in dimensions of human identity.

Dralyn S. 4A

2/6/2025 02:36:20 pm

Maybe it’s a mix of tactics—supporting independent Black-owned businesses directly, pressuring companies through public accountability campaigns, and when necessary, using boycotts strategically to create financial consequences. The key is making sure any action taken is part of a larger, organized effort that corporations can’t ignore.

Grant Z 4A

2/6/2025 02:41:28 pm

For companies such as Wal-Mart and Target to be pro everyone and support the DEI, but when things start to change they switch up. That makes me question wheatear or not they were being genuine and truly stood for the DEI, or was is just the companies stragey to get all races and ethnicitys to shop with them.

Kendell D HURRINGTON 4A

2/6/2025 02:43:48 pm

The long term benefits most certainly outweigh the short term discomfort the population will feel. Though my concern lies in the fact that this era is one of comfort instant gratification. When comparing protesters and activists of then to ones of today, its nearly laughable at how weak minded we can be. But its not necessarily our faults as we've grown up with a softer form of bigotry and persecution, leading us to not have the same hunger as those in the past. So yes, we do need to come together and boycott the major corporations. But is this society capable of such a stand?

Curlee A, 4A

2/7/2025 06:15:15 pm

Exactly, we as a society cannot replicate the past. People who suffered through war, or starved, or were beaten for their skin, or were tortured for what they believed in, had the will and drive to accomplish their goals. Even if that means sacrificing whatever they had to in order to get it. Change will never be easy, it will never be instant, it will never come at the click of a button, and it will surely not be us. All because, we will not stand for what we believe in.

Jahlil Hawkins

2/6/2025 02:56:56 pm

. Making informed choices and supporting movements that align with their beliefs can lead to a collective shift in corporate behaviors over time.

Hernandez M, 4A

2/6/2025 02:58:45 pm

It's hard for some to know the right move because even though boycotting these stores would be the best choice for them to feel the need for change, many people rely on these stores. Walmart is one of the most common stores specially in rural areas which means not everyone can choose to buy from a different place.As the story showed there's also other people that will be affected from it that sell their products on Walmart. It's not realistic because these places are so convenient but its the ebets way to make them change.

Smith R 8B

2/6/2025 09:52:04 pm

I agree, big companies such as Walmart that can be found everywhere & everywhere make it hard to support a bigger cause. Its convenience leaves people with ultimately no choice, sure online shopping is an option, but sometimes groceries are needed today rather than tomorrow.

Frank Jimenez 5B

2/7/2025 10:44:42 am

I agree, while ideally impactful, often clash with the realities of reliance and accessibility. Target and walmart corporations dominate rural and underserved areas making them unavoidable for many communities.

Flores A 4A

2/6/2025 03:53:57 pm

I believe that keep buying from target but from small black businesses will keep them afloat, but most people need to get groceries and will just buy it from Walmart or target since there the most available stores and options in them. if people want things to change they really need to find an alternative options or people will just continue to buy from them.

Lopez M 1A

2/7/2025 09:08:47 am

To truly make these boycotts work people have to find alternatives from Target and Walmart. Sometimes those alternatives will want to take advantage of people trying to find different grocery stores to shop at.They can raise prices which will most likely lead for people to go back to Target and Walmart making progress impossible to see.

Devonte James 6B

2/7/2025 03:17:19 pm

I agree i believe the could be other ways to go about it and still get the same results

Castillo V, 6B

2/7/2025 06:20:45 pm

Yes if they really want to make a difference they have to consider stop shopping from those companies.

Gonzalez S 4A link

2/7/2025 11:32:48 pm

I agree with your statement, people should look for alternative shopping stores for food options.

Teniente J. 1A

2/6/2025 06:21:35 pm

Boycotting big companies may make some communities feel better overall when trying to make them change, but many people relay on those stores for many years, and changing it for boycott without considering how it will others that don´t want to boycott because they get their resources so its a very hard choice to do among the people aganist the big companies.

Smith Sk 8B

2/7/2025 02:50:14 pm

I agree, Target and walmart corporations dominate rural and underserved areas making them unavoidable for many communities.

Guzman X 6B

2/6/2025 07:03:43 pm

Boycotting big companies like Target can hurt smaller businesses, especially Black-owned brands that rely on them. Tabitha Brown suggests supporting these small businesses while still shopping at Target. Some people think this isn’t enough to make a real change and prefer full boycotts to disrupt the system. It’s about balancing personal choices with the bigger picture of making a difference

Smith R 8B

2/6/2025 09:47:47 pm

While boycotting businesses such as Target, Walmart, & Amazon have the potential to hurt small businesses who rely on these companies, It Is a price one has to pay when it comes to boycotting. For example, right now in America people are boycotting Coca-Cola after they released a statement saying they were in support of immigration & trade policies that affect the Latino community. When boycotts happen, it has a ripple affect not only affecting these million dollar companies, but it also affects the working class, some who may even be the minorities being oppressed. This leads to a lack of demand requiring labor to be cut down ultimately leaving a person with no way to make money. While boycotting can harm businesses & its employees, it is a powerful message that I believe to be very effective in a world that revolves around money.

Luster J 3A

2/7/2025 08:27:57 am

My thoughts on the boycott of target is that the long-term gains definitely outweighs the short-term sacrifice. The "bold, unified stand can force companies to change" is exactly what's needed in order for people to be taken seriously. If no real action was taken people would be ignored and done wrong.

Gonzalez D. 1A

2/7/2025 07:49:58 pm

Yes I agree, it can be a bit inconvenient but it’s what’s needed so we get taken seriously.

Dilworth z 6B

2/7/2025 09:04:29 pm

I agree—sometimes the short-term sacrifice is necessary for long-term change. A bold, unified stand sends a strong message that can't be ignored. If people don’t take action, companies may continue to overlook the issues, but showing commitment through boycotts can force them to take real responsibility and make meaningful changes.

Alarcon A 3A

2/7/2025 08:46:17 am

It'll be difficult boycotting stores such as Walmart and Target especially if they are a big brand in which people depend on but if they don't support us there is no need for us to support them.

Smith Sk 8B

2/7/2025 02:51:56 pm

I agree, Some people think this isn’t enough to make a real change and prefer full boycotts to disrupt the system

Aiyanyo E 3A

2/7/2025 11:56:42 pm

It's difficult since these are big name brands and not small businesses. I agree that since these stores aren't supporting us, why should we give our money to them.

Lopez M 1A

2/7/2025 09:03:55 am

It makes no sense why such big companies like Target and Walmart would do a 360 on their decision for DEI. Target's decisions was especially shocking because they were promoting their commitment to diversity. I understand Tabitha's decision to tell others to support black owned brands that rely on companies like Target and Walmart as to not hurt them. It is a smart decision because it can also unite us as a society and encourage others to join the boycotts.

Rodriguez R. 4A

2/7/2025 12:40:15 pm

I agree, it was a weird move from these companies to switch up

Castillo V, 6B

2/7/2025 06:18:58 pm

I agree, it’s was shocking that both Walmart and Target just switched up on us out of the blue.

Alexandra .W ,6B

2/7/2025 09:04:46 am

that boycotting businesses that work for the DEI that make it hard for black-owners to work. and put there stuff around other Businesses

Colocho J 6B

2/7/2025 10:18:15 am

It raises questions about the long-term effectiveness of such boycotts and whether they can lead to meaningful changes. Its a complex issue with many layers of strategies to think about.

Frank Jimenez 5B

2/7/2025 10:36:03 am

Change rarely happens without friction. While selective shopping offers a compassionate compromise, it risks diluting the urgency of demands for equity. Corporations like target and walmart have the resources to absorb partial losses; they only act when their survival is at stake

Devonte James 6B

2/7/2025 03:15:02 pm

I agree because you will have to go thought this in your everyday life

Dilworth z 6b

2/7/2025 09:03:41 pm

You’re right—change often requires pressure. While selective shopping can push for action, it may not create enough urgency for real equity. Large corporations can absorb losses, so consistent collective action is needed to hold them accountable long-term.

williams 6B J

2/7/2025 10:50:22 am

I agree because you have to deal with these things when u get older and get a job

Rodriguez R. 4A

2/7/2025 12:29:11 pm

My thoughts on this issue is if this truly affects the person then they should do the full boycott on Target, Walmart, and Amazon and instead find a local small market and shop the black-owned brands and grocery there.

Tomas Ruiz 6B

2/7/2025 05:54:15 pm

My exact same way of thinking, to stop shopping at the big stores, and instead buy from the local stores

Alanis A, 3A

2/7/2025 11:12:08 pm

Yes I agree with this if someone feels strong about this issue they should fully boycott target and Walmart.

Aiyanyo E 3A

2/7/2025 11:58:17 pm

I agree, don't boycott small businesses and instead boycott big corporations who have been unfair to the American people. The loss of DEI initiatives from these companies is unfair to the people.

Garcia M 3A

2/7/2025 12:36:45 pm

Consumers face a challenging dilemma when deciding to initiate a boycott, weighing immediate sacrifices against potential long-term benefits. To create meaningful pressure on major retailers like Target, Walmart, and Amazon,consumers must balance their convenience with a collective commitment to uphold their values. Sustained efforts to demonstrate their purchasing power can lead to transformative change despite the challenges of convenience.

Curlee A, 4A

2/7/2025 06:10:58 pm

If this were said around five years ago, I'd whole heartedly agree. However, in the modern day and age, not so much. We cannot choose between convenance and commitment. Because we are so attached to convenance, that when these companies act out line, they can get away scot-free. We have to choose commitment OVER convenance, and that is the struggle no one wants to go through. Nobody wants to give up their luxury for what they believe in.

Smith Sk 8B

2/7/2025 02:48:44 pm

It will be hard boycotting Target and Walmart for those who actually depend from those big brands but if those brands dont support you then why support them

Tomas Ruiz 6B

2/7/2025 05:29:01 pm

Exactly, hence why we should buy our resources from Farmers Markets since it's a Local and come from Farmers who try to make a living from selling their produce.

Hayes T 8B

2/7/2025 09:11:54 pm

I agree with you a lot of people not gonna boycott target and Walmart cause most people shop there

Johnson C 8B

2/7/2025 02:50:13 pm

By making specific products a certain price range for certain audience. And by claiming that they are all about DEI, is a smart move on their end, to falsely give hope to consumers.

Malvaez M, 1A

2/7/2025 02:56:14 pm

Although people have negative views towards companies who have removed DEI such as Walmart and target, the impact of boycotting these companies will leave huge impact and message across on DEI, but it does affect and require the person to stop shopping. I believe that is your choice in which you choose to shop at, but me personally my family tries hard not to shop at brands who don't support DEI but some things are urgent that we need to get that require us to shop at those companies. Although I do believe boycotting these companies is the right choice to make people of color be heard, some people rely on those companies and can't afford to shop at other places.

Palacios R 1A

2/7/2025 09:17:00 pm

I agree with you, shoppers may prioritize the convenience of having everything they need in one place over other considerations.

Devonte James 6B

2/7/2025 03:14:22 pm

I don ´ t understand how you can say you for something like DEI and then go against everything that it stands for and i think we can find a way to boycott and still support small black business

Tomas Ruiz 6B

2/7/2025 05:25:57 pm

Well what I think about it is, The DEI thing is a weird thing for me to understand, and find it a bit harsh that Target and Walmart were doing the supporting the whole DEI thing. But they decided to stop due to political stuff, I think what we should do is buy stuff from other stores and giant names like Walmart and target.

Curlee A, 4A

2/7/2025 06:05:11 pm

I think people are forgetting that a boycott only works if the majority does it. Me personally, I could easily shop at more local stores and still get by, but not everyone can be in that position. Some people don't shop at these stores for convenance, but rather necessity. And these big names know this, they know some people are living paycheck to paycheck, they know some people are homeless, they know some people may not even have a car or access to public transport.
We used to be able to boycott companies and be ultimately unphased by the effects, because community was stronger back then. Now, people are completely dependent on these big companies to not only get by, but live. There is so much trust put into these corporations, that when they ultimately fail us, we can't even leave them behind where they belong.

Renteria R Anthony. 4 A

2/7/2025 08:49:00 pm

I agree, A boycott only has power when it’s widespread, but unfortunately, not everyone can afford to participate in one. For many, shopping at big-name stores isn’t a matter of convenience; it’s a matter of survival. These corporations know this and take advantage of people’s dependence on them.

Victorino H 8B

2/7/2025 11:48:05 pm

I agree a boycott would need a vast amount of people, but the corporations just have to much of a handle on customers and the role they play in them being able to get by.

Miles D 4A

2/7/2025 11:54:52 pm

I agree with you because there are a lot of people who dont go shopping at big name companies out of convienience but because they have to and its their only option.

Castillo V, 6B

2/7/2025 06:06:40 pm

In my opinion I think regardless if you purchase items that are from an African American business it doesn’t the fact that it’s falls under the stores that is a supporter of DEI. To make a change we have to prove that our money does affect their business since we will not be shopping there anymore.

Fuentez M 3A

2/7/2025 11:58:49 pm

I agree with what you say , regardless their products are at comapnies that support DEI . Many people will not stop shopping from their though, espiecally Walmart. White people wont stop shopping from target. It just depends how strongly people believe and want to see change. How committed they are to stop DEI

Gonzalez D. 1A

2/7/2025 07:48:17 pm

In my opinion, real change doesn’t come from inconvenience. Target and Walmart both rely on how much we spend there if we keep shopping even if it’s selectively they won’t be affected by it a full boycott might be inconvenient but it’s what will bring us change.

Lopez H 4A

2/7/2025 09:10:09 pm

Exactly, only until everyone fully stops shopping there and boycotts completely, then that’s when change will fully happen.

Renteria R. Anthony. 4A

2/7/2025 08:47:08 pm

It’s frustrating when companies like Target and Walmart publicly support DEI but then act in ways that contradict those values. The message of inequality is clear, and a boycott could be an effective response. Focusing on supporting black-owned businesses is a smart and impactful strategy, as it helps shift the narrative and encourages real change. Ultimately, if consumers unite in making these choices, it sends a strong message to large corporations like Target about the importance of aligning their actions with their stated principles.

Lopez H 4A

2/7/2025 09:09:19 pm

Exactly, so many companies showing their true colors towards people of color is truly disappointing, and yes, shifting sales and overall support to businesses from people of color, if everyone collectively bands together to boycott businesses then it would definitely send a strong message.

Dilworth Z 6b

2/7/2025 09:02:36 pm

Companies that embrace DEI can foster innovation, improve employee engagement, and reflect societal values. It attracts a diverse talent pool and creates a more inclusive environment. However, for DEI to be effective, it needs to go beyond surface-level efforts and address deeper systemic issues. When done right, DEI can greatly benefit company culture and overall success.

Alvarez J 8B

2/7/2025 11:49:42 pm

DEI is a great policy that ultimately represents equality so it would be a poor strategy for companies trying to not have that policy.

Lopez H 4A

2/7/2025 09:03:55 pm

From my perspective, if a company doesn’t appreciate people of color, when why would they take our money, and profit from it? even though the change to boycotting these stores is going to be a tad more uncomfortable or inconvenient but if in the future it advances change for the better then it is worth it in the end, it is truly sad to see how many companies and brands turn their backs and show their true colors towards people of color, hopefully these boycotts promote change.

Alvarez J 8B

2/7/2025 11:51:39 pm

I agree why would anyone want to buy from someone who doesn't even like you.

Presas A 6B

2/9/2025 10:52:44 am

It is frustrating and disheartening to see companies profit from communities they don't fully value or support. If a company doesn't respect people of color, it does raise the question of why they should continue to benefit from our spending power.

Cavazos N 6B

2/9/2025 11:25:43 pm

100% agree, if these companies don't care about you why should you care about them.

Hayes T 8b

2/7/2025 09:09:19 pm

I believe that what the big companies are doing will soon end up hurting smaller businesses. This would later affect the lives of those who are behind these brands therefore having the possibility of not being able to support their families that may have.

Fuentez M 3A

2/7/2025 11:55:06 pm

I dont think boycotting will help as much it might help some people but not many. I know it will stay the same because the majority who shop at target are white people not colored. so i know that their businesses will still grow

Palacios R 1A

2/7/2025 09:22:17 pm

I would still shop as long as the people are respectful. Sometimes there's competitive prices and discounts that appear on budget. However, some people might think that their actions alone won't make a difference, causing them to continue their usual shopping habits.

Cozine S 3A

2/7/2025 11:21:01 pm

I agree not everyone is going to get equal and fair prices

Alanis A , 3A

2/7/2025 10:36:11 pm

I believe that real change usually needs strong teamwork, even if it's not easy or has immediate costs. History shows that putting economic pressure on people can be a strong way to make change happen, like what happened during the Montgomery Bus Boycott. If businesses like Target and Walmart aren't heavily affected financially, they have no reason to change their approach to DEI programs.

Cozine S 3A

2/7/2025 11:20:14 pm

I understand Tabitha's decision to tell others to support black owned brands that rely on companies like Target and Walmart as to not hurt them.

Palacios R 1A

2/8/2025 12:23:51 pm

After looking up, some users comments have accused Target of "selling out," and others have simply commented "no," "nope" and "traitor". I say that you can boycott a company if your boycott only ends once you get what you want.

Gonzalez S 4A link

2/7/2025 11:39:15 pm

By shopping at other stores it helps us alternative methods to avoid big companies for boycott. DEI is a decision that people have to help prioritize our values and impact for a better change.

Alvarez J 8B

2/7/2025 11:44:56 pm

I believe her method is very smart and strategic. I think this because not buying from big business like that is maybe difficult for the everyday person but if you buy only black products or a product from a small business it will send a point across and they will have to reconsider their decision.

Victorino H 8B

2/7/2025 11:46:10 pm

I believe that the main way people would be able to make companies like Walmart, target, and Amazon feel pressure is boycotting, but this would be nearly impossible because of the vast amount of people that would be needed, as a company like Amazon is very convenient for people especially with free shipping, the only way where we would get enough people to boycott Walmart, target, or Amazon in order to pressure them into making change would be to have probably the biggest unification of people in the history of the world.

Presas A 6B

2/9/2025 10:48:00 am

You bring up an excellent point about the difficulty of organizing a widespread boycott against major companies like Walmart, Target, and Amazon, especially given how convenient and ingrained they are in people's lives. It's true that achieving the level of unification necessary to make a significant impact would be a massive challenge.

Miles D 4A

2/7/2025 11:52:52 pm

I think that a boycott would only work if majority of people all came together and caused a big enough scene for the company they are boycotting to actually care. With how split people are about boycotting these companies I don't think anything will actually happen, but I understand why there are people who want to because they are frusterated or upset with how these big name companies are dealing with the U.S. cutting DEI initiatives.

Hernandez I 6b

2/8/2025 05:10:32 pm

i agree

Cavazos N 6B

2/9/2025 11:24:47 pm

People should still boycott even if it doesn't do anything

Fuentez M,3A

2/7/2025 11:53:22 pm

If a company does not support people of color why still serve us? i feel like boycotting will make a diffrence but at the same time not . Not many colored people shop at target. Its usually the white population. If u never shopped there then whats the point of boycotting if nothing is changing if you never shopped there .

Aiyanyo E 3A

2/7/2025 11:54:38 pm

By boycotting these big store corporations, it's really doing more harm than good for black owned brands who rely on these sales from superstores to stay in business. However, it's really disappointing how Walmart and Target decided to stop with DEI initiatives. It's still not a reason to boycott and hurt the small business that are on our side.

Hernandez I 6b

2/8/2025 05:10:15 pm

i agree the boycotts would do more harm than good

Knowles K 1A

2/8/2025 12:10:22 am

I believe that if people don’t like your brand due to it not supporting Black Owned Businesses they have the right to boycott, everyone do what is best for them.

Hernandez I 6b

2/8/2025 05:09:41 pm

i believe that boycotting is necessary in some circumstances in this particular one boycotting those huge businesses can have a harmful affect on a ton of people and smaller businesses.

Rodriguez Y. 3A

2/8/2025 06:31:18 pm

DEI is important for everyone, colored people and Hispanics get discriminated and taken advantage of of us but because of this is getting removed it's just going to make everyone whos got a different color of skin and different characteristic be left with no support. People will take advatnge and will probably not hire them, not give them a place to stay at and make it harder for this people.

Presas A 6B

2/9/2025 10:42:57 am

This situations highlights the tension between maintaining progress on DEI initiatives and the political of societal pressure that sometimes undermine them.Companies like Target and Walmart have immense influence, and when they backtrack on their commitments, it can feel like a betrayal of the values they once championed. Tabitha Brown's suggestion to selectively support Black-owned brands within these companies is thoughtful and pragmatic.It acknowledges that an all out boycott can unintentionally harm the very communities we aim to uplift. But however it selective support enough to hold corporations accountable for their actions.

Cavazos N 6B

2/9/2025 11:22:38 pm

I believe that people who disagree with Target’s or any stores' decisions to remove DEI's should go full boycott on them and don’t buy any of their products, as the stores would be nothing without their consumers. If people still want to support small black businesses they should buy straight from the source and not buy their products from a third party like Target.

Comments are closed.

Mixed Ink

Mixed Ink is our class blog, the window into our souls. It was designed to improve students' writing, critical thinking and communication skills by giving them a platform to provide meaningful content based on their interpretation of what they see.

Although the students receive a grade based on a rubric for completing this assignment, they are not graded on complexity of thought. This is a place where students of all levels can freely, confidently and creatively express themselves and their opinions in a nonjudgmental platform. They are required to respond to and critique each other, but degradation, slander, lewdness, etc., will not be tolerated.

Bridge Builders

All subjects are vital to learning, but English is the bridge of communication. So let's build the arch, one word at a time...

Grading Rubric

Learning Objectives

Communicate effectively
Be aware of current events
Write concisely
Boost critical thinking skills
Be accountable
Follow directions
Have a voice about what goes on in the world around you

DEI or DIE

Mixed Ink

Bridge Builders

Grading Rubric

Archives

Categories