English Fury
  • Students
  • Parents
  • MixedInk
  • Contact Us

I Reckon It's 50/50 True

12/8/2025

138 Comments

 
Picture
After watching Sean “Diddy” Combs: The Reckoning, society is wrestling with a hard question: How do we hold powerful people accountable when the truth comes out years later, and how do we protect those who come forward?

In the documentary, survivors describe harm that stayed hidden because of fame, influence, fear, and money. At the same time, some people argue that public opinion can move faster than the legal system, creating a “trial by social media.”

What does accountability look like in a world where influence can silence people or distort consequences and how can we explore the tension between justice, celebrity culture, and the way society responds when power is abused.
Let's Write! If you know that someone with cultural power is abusive, mean, and violent, and have hurt many people in a number of violent, cruel, demeaning, and financially harmful ways, but then find out that they were severely abused as small children, is their behavior excusable? Why or Why not?
INSTRUCTIONS

​1. INCLUDE: Last Name, First Initial, AND Class Block. You do not have to include an email address or a website.

2. Respond to the post. Read the entire post, including watching any videos or reading any articles attached. Do not post vague or ambiguous commentary. Your post should have depth, be thoughtful, and provide specific, meaningful insight. Make sure it addresses the topic and encourages reflection, discussion, or a connection.

3. You MUST comment on at least TWO other posts from any student in any class. Your replies cannot be identical comments on different posts and posting shallow comments such as "I agree" or "I disagree" will earn you a zero. Make sure your reply addresses the comment that you are responding to.

4. Language. Do NOT use profanity. Vague or repeated responses will not be accepted in your post or replies.
​
5. Disrespectful comments will not be accepted and will result in a zero whether you do the assignment or not. 


REMINDERS

**Set a weekly alarm or calendar timer. 
Whatever you do to remember other important events, I'd do the same for this assignment.

**Don't wait until the last minute. Telling me that you didn't do the assignment on Friday because you broke your leg, for example, on Thursday will not do anything for you when you've had a week. Be responsible and accountable.

**How to post. Click in the top right hand corner or the lower left hand corner where it says Comments to access the discussion board. Once there, scroll to the bottom of the page to post a Reply. After, choose comments from at least two students from any class and Reply to what they wrote.
​
CAUTION!! Do NOT embarrass me, yourself, your class, the English department, the school, your family or your upbringing with tasteless, meaningless comments. This is for a grade.

DISCLAIMER: If you do not respond AND comment on TWO others, you will not receive credit for this assignment. If you do not write your name correctly, and I don't see your work, you will not receive credit for this assignment. If you use profanity, you will not receive credit for the work. It's all or nothing.

WARNING: If you post even one second past midnight, your comment might appear to be posted, but as soon as it is opened to be graded, it will automatically delete.


​​Due Fri., December 12, 11:59 p.m. CST
138 Comments
Newbill, T 1A
12/9/2025 09:03:45 am

Absolutely not. having trauma from your childhood does not make it okay for you to traumatize and hurt others as an adult. why would that excuse your behavior to make people's lives worse because of what you went through as a child ? a full grown adult is fully aware of their actions. u always have a choice in doing good and doing bad. i get that "hurt people,hurt people " and going through such abuse as a child may alter the way you move and think but that doesn't justify and make it okay.

Reply
Vasquez, L 1A
12/9/2025 09:39:02 am

Childhood trauma can help explain why someone grows into harmful behaviors, but it doesn’t excuse the damage they choose to inflict on others once they have power and control over their actions. We can acknowledge their past with empathy while still holding them fully accountable for the pain they cause in the present.

Reply
Carpenter Zachary 2a
12/9/2025 11:19:59 am

i agree with this it can explain why but there is still no excuse they have to be accountable for the actions because hurting people is not right

Valdez, K 2A
12/10/2025 09:16:20 am

I agree with the sentiment that we can acknowledge their past with empathy while still holding them accountable for what they do in the present because growing as a person is possible and no amount of suffering in the past is a solid factor that inevitably makes you doomed to be "evil".

Ruiz K 2A
12/10/2025 09:19:15 am

I would agree with this cause, people don't know how to handle major trauma

Nunez B 7B
12/10/2025 01:33:50 pm

I agree because that dosents justify someones actions no matter what their childhood looked like they shouldn't be the reason why someone elses childhood gets ruined.

Garcia, K 1A
12/12/2025 11:43:56 am

i agree everyone should be held accountable for their actions even if they've been abused in the past, it's no reason for them to hurt others.

Maliyah K 3A
12/15/2025 02:49:01 pm

I agree with you, especially when you said that trauma can explain behavior but doesn’t excuse it. I like how you mentioned power and control, because once someone has that, they also have responsibility. Having empathy for someone’s past is important, but it shouldn’t come at the cost of ignoring the harm they cause to others.

Alvarado A 2A
12/17/2025 11:11:00 am

I agree with this because just because you have past trauma does not mean you should not be held accountable for their actions.

Gonzalez,A 2A
12/17/2025 11:19:38 am

I agree with this even though there is no excuse to be hurting people even though sometimes people may not know know how to handle their trauma and may just treat others any type of way.

Carpenter Zachary 2a
12/9/2025 11:17:39 am

I agree with everything people will have the choice to choose its up to them to choose what is right.

Reply
Sean Patino 5B
12/18/2025 09:51:24 am

I agree because since you've been through it you know how it feels so its your choice if you want to keep going with it . But not having that be your excuse of why you do it .

York,A 2a
12/9/2025 12:26:01 pm

I agree with you past trauma can explain someone’s struggles, but it doesn’t excuse harming others. Accountability means recognizing pain without allowing it to become a justification for causing new harm.

Reply
Ruiz K 2A
12/10/2025 09:20:19 am

I agree cause, people have to know how to take accountability for there actions that can be prevented.

Alvarado A 2A
12/17/2025 11:12:21 am

I agree with this because even if you have childhood trauma you can not keep using it as an excuse for your actions especially if you've grown since that time

Valdez, K 2A
12/10/2025 09:09:53 am

You made an amazing point. Something that happened to you as a kid should not be an excuse for what you do as an adult because as an adult you are fully aware of what you are doing and the option to do better is always available. At some point people try to use their pain to disguise ignorance.

Reply
Hurtado J 7B
12/10/2025 01:28:44 pm

I agree with this statement because why should there be an excuse for hurting others just because you were hurt doesn't mean everybody should go through what you gone through

Reply
Israel Hernandez
12/11/2025 08:30:15 am

I agree a 100% because being hurt doesn’t give someone the right to hurt others. Just because a person went through pain doesn’t mean everyone else should have to feel it too. People still have a choice, and they should be held responsible for what they do.

Roilen B 2A
12/17/2025 10:21:06 am

I 100% agree with what you're saying you should not want the same outcome for others knowing what you have already gone through.

jaylon v 2a
12/19/2025 10:38:33 am

i agree no excuse they have to be speaking for they action the actions because hurting people is not right

Lazariah Powell 7B
12/10/2025 01:45:55 pm

I 100% agree with what you're saying you should not want the same outcome for others knowing what you have already gone through.

Reply
Cordova Armani 7B
12/11/2025 11:34:45 pm

I completely agree with your comment they are full grown adults so they should take accountability of their doing including whoever causes them to have the trama. They are fully aware of what they are doing. Me being open minded I could understand a little where they are coming from but it shouldn't be an excuse to push it onto someone else due to their being multiple help resources out there.

Reply
Watson S 1A
12/12/2025 01:37:11 am

I agree with what you said, yes hurt people hurt people. As well as them being abused doesn't make it right for them to take their trauma out on innocent people. Everyone is responsible for their actions.

Reply
Skylar B. 6B
12/12/2025 09:06:18 am

I see your point exactly just because you have trauma from your past that does not mean you get the free pass to traumatize others. You should want to help them because you know the pain that can cause them and the ongoing damaged as well.

Reply
Tylen Green 3A
12/17/2025 11:44:38 am

I agree people can definitely control how they feel and how they act

Alfaro K 1A
12/15/2025 11:08:44 pm

I agree with your point that childhood trauma does not excuse harming others, especially when someone is a full-grown adult who understands their actions. I also like how you acknowledged the phrase “hurt people hurt people” but clearly explained that understanding the cause of someone’s behavior is not the same as justifying it. Your comment makes it clear that while trauma can affect how a person thinks and acts, personal responsibility and the choice to do good still matter.

Reply
Jacobs K 7B
12/17/2025 09:55:20 am

Not everyone may be aware of what they're doing and the harm they're causing to others. There are psychological disorders that can cause people to act out and have no recollection of it and not be mentally conscious in the moment. Overall the behavior itself isn't excusable but sometimes it truly may be uncontrollable.

Reply
Amanda Lama 5B
12/18/2025 09:39:58 am

I agree there can be many stuff wrong with people but that doesn't excuse any type of behavior.

Tylen Green 3A
12/17/2025 01:28:31 pm

I agree with the idea that an adult's past trauma doesn't excuse their current actions. By the time you are a full-grown adult, you are responsible for how you treat other people.

Reply
Calito V.
12/18/2025 09:53:10 am

I agree because your trauma shouldn't be an excuse to traumatize other people. If you are traumatized you should try and find help as it can prevent others from feeling what you feel as a child.

Reply
jaylon v 2a
12/19/2025 10:39:33 am

I agree because your trauma shouldn't be an excuse to traumatize other people cant always make that as a excuse

Roilen Beal
12/9/2025 11:11:34 am

Childhood trauma can help explain why someone grows into harmful behaviors, but it doesn’t excuse the damage they choose to inflict on others once they have power and control.

Reply
York,A 2a
12/9/2025 12:29:44 pm

I agree understanding trauma gives context, but accountability matters because choices and actions still cause real harm.

Reply
Jeremiah R, 7B
12/12/2025 11:33:24 am

Yes I also agree with your opinion , your experiences shouldn't reflect on what you do in the future.

Hurtado J 7B
12/10/2025 01:30:27 pm

I agree childhood trauma can be the reason for the way someone reacts to certain situations but it doesn't make it okay to harm others

Reply
Nunez B 7B
12/10/2025 01:32:12 pm

I agree because that dosents excuse what that person has done they don't get a pass just cause they went through the same thing.

Reply
Lazariah Powell 7B
12/10/2025 01:51:00 pm

I agree people can definitely control how they feel and how they act although they might of had trauma growing up it is not a valid excuse.

Reply
Jeremiah R, 7B
12/12/2025 11:32:22 am

I strongly am siding with you , I believe that trauma shouldn't be used as an excuse to try to avoid punishment or law.

Reply
Martinez G 7B
12/12/2025 01:23:00 pm

I agree with everything you have said. Their harmful actions are never excused. The trauma they experienced only explains the root cause.

Reply
Scales A 7B
12/18/2025 10:56:36 am

I agree the trauma that you went thru shouldn't be used as a excuse to do the same to others.

Reply
Carpenter, Z 2A
12/9/2025 11:16:05 am

In my opinion its not excusable but its also not surprising that some people who get beat on and abused tend to do the same thing later on in life. it starts with 1 parent and their childhood trauma is there forever. And you never know your parents may have also got beat on so they take it out on you.

Reply
Israel Hernandez
12/11/2025 08:28:51 am

I agree because cycles of abuse are real. When someone grows up in a violent home, it can shape how they act later. Like you said, trauma doesn’t excuse hurting others, but it explains why it happens. That’s why breaking the cycle and choosing healing is so important.

Reply
Fraire Y 1A
12/11/2025 10:59:44 am

Yes like you said having trauma dose not excuse hurting others and also if you can just decide to get help so you can brake the cycle and choose healing.

Jacobs K 7B
12/17/2025 10:01:36 am

I see where you're coming from is can be easy for someone who's experienced abusive situations to inflict it on someone else. specially since they may see it as a way of trying to take control by doing what was don't to them to somebody else. Even though they may be trying to do something that can help them cope with their trauma its not an excuse for giving it to someone else.

Reply
York,A 2A
12/9/2025 12:23:31 pm

Childhood trauma may explain someone’s behavior, but it does not excuse harming others. people suffer and choose healing instead of violence. Excusing abuse risks normalizing cycles of harm.True accountability recognizes both their past pain and the damage they caused

Reply
Maliyah K 3A
12/15/2025 02:49:42 pm

I agree with what you said, especially the part about people choosing healing instead of violence. That really stood out to me because it shows that trauma doesn’t automatically lead to abuse.

Reply
Valdez K 2A
12/10/2025 09:04:53 am

While someones upbringing can explain their actions and why they behave and think the way they do, it doesn't give them a free pass to be a horrible person and spread the trauma. When someone goes through difficult experiences, it's not their job to get retribution and drag other people into their mud. If everyone that went through hardships decided to get even with everyone around them and make everyone miserable just because they were/are unhappy, then the world would be full of miserable people and a constant chain of people passing on the pain and hurt.

Reply
Skylar B. 6B
12/12/2025 08:52:11 am

You have an amazing point if the world was really like that we all would be miserable because there will be a constant void that never will be filled.

Reply
Garcia, K 1A
12/12/2025 11:47:23 am

i completely agree, yes hurt people hurt people but its still no reason to do so, if it was acceptable for people to do that the world would be miserable and full of hatred, people should not hurt people regardless of being abused in the past.

Reply
Newbill T 1A
12/12/2025 02:32:07 pm

most people went through hard things growing up . so I understand your point . If everyone took their anger out on innocent just because of something that happened as a child this world would be so much more dangerous .

Reply
Washington B 1A
12/12/2025 10:38:08 pm

i agree with your point of veiw because there will always be a void that never be filled.

Reply
Gonzalez,A 2A
12/17/2025 11:23:14 am

I agree with this because hurt people do hurt people and there's still no reason to hurt others,and if everyone was just so full of anger this world would be 10x more worster than what it is now.

Reply
Ruiz K 2A
12/10/2025 09:17:38 am

Its a valid reason why people do don't know how to act cause what happens in there childhood. People can get emotionally scar from the past and never know how to recover from it. You just have to accept that not all people can take accountability that they can't stop.

Reply
Taneilyha jones-blunt
12/10/2025 01:33:45 pm

I disagree with you because even though people may not know how to act because of their past, that still does not excuse harming others. Not everyone learns accountability the same way, but that does not mean their actions suddenly become okay. Understanding their past is important, but it does not erase the damage they cause.

Reply
Israel H
12/19/2025 11:51:04 am

I liked how you said accountability should match the level of influence someone has, and that’s true when powerful people hurt others, the impact is bigger.

Newbill T 1A
12/12/2025 02:35:29 pm

that's why there people to help you if your going through something so traumatic that you cant handle yourself. there are therapist , doctors, counselors, and many more . So many things and resources for a child or adult that are " scarred" . so its never acceptable for someone to do bad onto others . especially as an full grown adult.

Reply
Khloe KIng 5B
12/17/2025 08:56:20 am

I agree because when trauma feels overwhelming, there are therapists, doctors, and counselors ready to help. Both children and adults have resources to heal, so hurting others is never acceptable.

Hurtado J 7B
12/10/2025 12:41:25 pm

Childhood trauma should not be the excuse to repeat and create the trauma on others, I believe that you shouldn't repeat the cycle and hurt other and make them go through the same trauma it is about stopping the cycle not to keep growing it.

Reply
Taneilyha jones-blunt 7b
12/10/2025 01:32:26 pm

I agree with you because trauma should not be a reason to hurt other people. Even if someone was treated badly as a child, it does not mean they should repeat that cycle. your comment makes sense because stopping the cycle is the only way to keep others from going through the same pain.

Reply
Luna W. 1A
12/17/2025 09:10:38 am

I absolutely agree with this. There is no need to pass it on to other innocent people when you can heal and grow from it.

Reply
Lazariah P 7B
12/10/2025 12:42:43 pm

I understand going through things as children and it can effect childhood behavior but I don't think that's an excuse for the way someone acts and behaves towards others because if you know how that made you feel why in the world you you want to return that energy to another well being. If you know you're struggling and going through things from your past you should want to get any type of help you can get so that you're not struggling the rest of your life.

Reply
Fraire Y 1A
12/11/2025 10:55:48 am

Yes there is ways that people can get help so that they are not affecting others and they can also help them selfs getting to help your self is the better thing to do like you said.

Reply
Rubio I 1A
12/11/2025 06:56:48 pm

I agree 100% with this statement if you know what being abused can do to a person why ever want to make someone else go through that pain. It's not right and will never be excusable.

Reply
Watson S 1A
12/12/2025 01:40:48 am

Yes, I agree that trauma affects behaviors and they shouldn't effect how you treat others that have don't nothing to you. If someone is struggling with letting go of their past, they should try to talk to a professional about it instead of trying to do what their abuser did to them.

Reply
Washington B 1A
12/12/2025 10:41:01 pm

yes because if you were abused you'd understand what they grew up with and are dealing with but it isnt right and will never be an excuse

Reply
Alfaro K 1A
12/15/2025 11:10:07 pm

I like how you pointed out that experiencing pain as a child should actually make someone less willing to hurt others, not more. Your comment also does a good job emphasizing personal responsibility, especially when you mentioned that people should seek help if they know they are struggling. It shows that while trauma can affect someone, choosing healing and growth is a better response than passing that pain on to others.

Reply
Taneilyha Jones-Blunt
12/10/2025 01:29:35 pm

Their behavior is not excusable. Knowing they were abused as children can help explain why they act the way they do, but it does not make the harm they cause okay. Once someone has power, they still have a responsibility to make better choices and not repeat the cycle of abuse. Their past may explain their actions, but it does not erase the pain they cause or the accountability they owe.

Reply
Rubio I 1A
12/11/2025 07:05:13 pm

Exactly i agree with your statement because if someone is more "powerful" than other people it should actually encourage them to do more good since they have more possible influence. So a powerful person doing wrong just because they were abused in the past will never make it right.

Reply
Nunez B 7B
12/10/2025 01:30:43 pm

A lot of people suffer in their chillhood which cause them to have a lot of problems while growing up but if that person knows how bad it is or how much damage it creates then why would that person go and do it someone else. I don't think their behaviour is excusable.

Reply
Chavez D. 7B
12/10/2025 02:15:13 pm

I agree with your comment. It's not excusable to harm another person and to pass that trauma down when you absolutely know how harmful it is to you.

Reply
Larios A. 7B
12/12/2025 10:45:02 am

I agree with your comment as there are people with severe trust issues and what not. They are still aware of their actions compared to other people who can't control their mind and body.

Reply
Tejada D 1A
12/12/2025 01:30:26 pm

I also think the same thing. If you went through something traumatic as a child you don't want other people to go through the same thing.

Reply
Chavez D. 7B
12/10/2025 01:37:26 pm

It is absolutely not excusable to harm another person just because you had childhood trauma. I can understand how that childhood trauma can somehow alter your view, but still, you should NEVER harm another person just because you got harmed as a child. At the end of the day, I think that this is a deplorable action. You should never pass on your trauma to another person.

Reply
Gracie Ramos
12/12/2025 08:54:33 am

I agree with the statement that if you experience a traumatic childhood, it's your responsibility as an adult to seek help. And that you should never pass on your trauma to another person.

Reply
Scales A 7B
12/10/2025 02:12:09 pm

Childhood trauma should not be excusable to cause harmful activites to others. It is known that the trauma you experience can cause the way you view things more than other people around you. but it is still not right to do what was done to your to the people around you.

Reply
Cordova Armani 7B
12/11/2025 11:31:12 pm

I agree with this comment especially the part where you said you experience can cause the way you view things more than other people around you. This is more than just a sentence being written this is a real life experience for many people today. People who were physically abused compared to not being abused especially parents from today.They think just because they went through it and it provided some "discipline" within them which it really didn't they can put it off on their kids continuing this repeated cycle of trauma

Reply
Israel Hernandez
12/10/2025 04:21:43 pm

I don’t think abuse as a child excuses hurting others later i personally think trauma can explain someone’s struggles, but it doesn’t give them the right to be violent or cruel. Because many people go through hard childhoods and still choose not to harm others. If we excuse bad behavior because of past pain, we ignore the victims who suffered.

Reply
Fraire.Y 1A
12/11/2025 10:51:01 am

Childhood trauma is not a excuse to hurt anyone later on in life,yes it dose explain struggle that people might have later but it dose not justify hurting someone just because you got hurt doesn't mean that you can hurt other people.

Reply
Tylen Green 3A
12/11/2025 12:23:14 pm

Childhood trauma should not be the excuse to repeat and create the trauma on others, I believe that you shouldn't repeat the cycle

Reply
Rubio I 1A
12/11/2025 06:55:37 pm

I believe that it is absolutely not acceptable for someone to abuse others just because they were abused although this doesn't mean that I don't think they should find help to heal possible trauma but I don't think its fair at all to abuse someone else that did nothing wrong.

Reply
Aamory Avalos 7b
12/12/2025 11:21:40 am

I completely agree with you. Hurting others just because you were hurt isn't okay. There are different solutions out there, whether it's going to therapy or finding an outlet to let the pain out in a positive way.

Reply
Cordova Armani 7B
12/11/2025 11:26:43 pm

Childhood trauma should be no excusable for showing wrongdoing.Using your trauma to create significant trauma onto someone should never be the answer just to fulfill what was lost in your childhood. Everyone in some way or form goes through trauma so its no excuse for you.Although some tramas can lead to physiological affects like if you were SA you tend to become the SA er or be hypersexual there are alternative ways to change and cope with those things you are dealing with.

Reply
Martinez G 7B
12/16/2025 11:25:13 am

I agree with everything you have said. I especially agree with the second sentence. You should never put someone else through what you have been through. Or what you haven't been through.

Reply
Watson S 1A
12/12/2025 01:44:50 am

I am a firm believer that everyone has a choice to be who they want. I understand that the way you grow up has a lot to do with how you do things as an adult. However, how you deal with it is completely your choice. Choosing to abuse others because you were abused isn't an excuse. It's sad that anyone would want innocent people to feel the pain they felt, instead of trying to make the world better by eliminating the people that cause issues like this.

Reply
Gracie Ramos
12/12/2025 08:50:06 am

I agree that if you have experienced severe trauma, it's your responsibility to get help like a therapist so you are able to process through it. And that you are able to develop the skills that make you a mature adult.

Reply
Martinez J 7B
12/12/2025 01:18:57 pm

I completely agree with your belief, knowing the feeling of the pain you experience you wouldn't want to share it with others.

Reply
Gracie Ramos
12/12/2025 08:36:24 am

Just because you have face traumatic challenges in your childhood, it doesn't excuse or justify your actions. If a person has severely harmed a person or multiple people there are always consequences. You are not entitled to act a certain way because you were abused.

Reply
Tejada D 1A
12/12/2025 01:28:16 pm

Trauma as a kid can shape a person into something unstable and should get the necessary help they need so they cant hurt themselves or other people

Reply
Skylar B. 6B
12/12/2025 08:46:17 am

No absolutely not their behavior is not excusable just because of their background or trauma. Your trauma does not always define who you you, you could use that pain to help people instead of hurt people.

Reply
Larios A. 7B
12/12/2025 10:43:36 am

I think trauma to a child can change their future and the way they will grow up to be adults. Even adults that go through something don't stay the same. It's not excusable but those who commit crimes that aren't mentally well are placed in an asylum.

Reply
Parada E 2A
12/17/2025 10:34:51 am

I agree trauma can shape someones future, but it doesn’t excuse harming others. Mental health care is important yet accountability still matters.

Reply
Aamory Avalos 7B
12/12/2025 11:17:33 am

Childhood trauma can seriously affect how someone grows up and how they handle different situations later in their life. It shapes a person's mindset, but it doesn't control the type of person they become. Experiencing such trauma does not excuse hurting others, no matter what. Everyone has choices, so at some point, everyone has to take responsibility for those choices.

Reply
Parada E 2A
12/17/2025 10:35:58 am

trauma can shape someones mindset, but you’re right that it doesn’t excuse harming others. Responsibility for choices is key!!!

Reply
Calito V.
12/18/2025 09:59:51 am

I agree because people have a choice and if you have trauma you should get help before you do something that can get you in trouble or hurt.

Reply
Jeremiah R, 7B
12/12/2025 11:30:18 am

Although childhood trauma is something unfortunately people have to live and grow up with , I don't think its an excuse for your actions or what you do in life . You know how you felt when those series of events happened to you and how enclosed it made you feel .. Why deliver that same affect , feelings and enclosure to other people. Diddy should get executed.by a Firing squad on LIVE TV

Reply
Israel H
12/19/2025 11:50:11 am

I agree with your point that trauma can explain behavior but doesn’t excuse it. You made me think about how important therapy and support systems are for breaking harmful cycles.

Reply
Garcia K 1A
12/12/2025 11:41:31 am

While childhood trauma can significantly impact a persons development and behavior, it does not remove their responsibility for the harm they inflict on others, it should not excuse the behavior itself. Accountability requires that individuals are held responsible for their actions, regardless of their past experiences.

Reply
Chavez D. 7B
12/12/2025 12:25:55 pm

I agree that childhood trauma can significantly impact a person's development and behavior in a major way that we probably still don't know about. I also do agree that a person should be held accountable regardless of their experience.

Reply
Martinez J 7B
12/12/2025 12:40:19 pm

i agree with you and how trauma should never be an excuse for behaving the way he treats others.

Reply
Taylor, M 7B
12/16/2025 12:13:55 pm

They should be held just accountable as anyone, their past and social status shouldn't exempt them from punishment.

Reply
Martinez J 7B
12/12/2025 12:38:02 pm

Although the childhood trauma must have affected him badly, it does not excuse the fact that he acted the same way to a lot more people and caused almost a whole generation of music to fear their careers. In which created the same trauma or even worse than his own to all of the innocent people involved under his influence. Being accountable for your actions is facing what you have done and confessing to who you hurt and who was by your side to give justice to those who lost their lives due to his actions.

Reply
Taylor, M 7B
12/16/2025 12:05:47 pm

You're right it's not excusable, they should be treated the same and punished.

Reply
Martinez G 7B
12/12/2025 01:16:59 pm

A lot of people in power do a lot of bad things. Those same people had bad childhood experiences. Even though they went through those events, it doesn't justify their actions. It only explains why they turned out to who they are today.

Reply
Luna W. 1A
12/17/2025 09:07:56 am

I agree with you, having that childhood experience can shape on who the person is today.

Reply
Tejada D, 1A
12/12/2025 01:26:29 pm

I believe it is not excusable to treat other people in a way that makes them feel scared,unsafe or uncomfortable because of childhood trauma.You don't want people to go through bad experiences like you have.

Reply
Thorpe Zamyriah, 7B
12/16/2025 12:21:14 pm

I agree, their actions and behavior isnt excusable or acceptable. So they just need to be able to treat people how they wanna be treated so if they keep treating their own peers like that then they´ll adapt from that.

Reply
Sean Patino 5B
12/18/2025 09:46:20 am

I agree because just because you had to deal with it growing up doesn't mean its your job to put others through it.

Washington B 1A
12/12/2025 10:34:43 pm

i believe it isnt an exuse to treat people in certain way because of the way your how you grew up like scared, unsafe,or uncomforable.Although childhood trauma is something unfortunately people have to live and grow up with , I don't think its an excuse for your actions or what you do in life

Reply
Thorpe, Zamyriah 7B
12/16/2025 12:23:22 pm

i agree, i believe that it never should be a thought in a parent, or aunt or grandparents or peer mind to put their hands on someone and causing them all that trauma.

Reply
Gathu 1A
12/16/2025 06:16:49 pm

Childhood trauma may shape how someone acts, but it doesn’t justify hurting others.can feel empathy for what someone has been through, everyone is still responsible for how they treat people in their life

Reply
Dominguez , J 1A
12/17/2025 09:05:47 am

I agree with Gathu because just cause you grew up different from someone else shouldn't mean you go do bad stuff and mistreat others

nevaeh R 5b
12/18/2025 09:15:44 am

I agree with you. Childhood trauma can explain why someone struggles, but it doesn’t excuse mistreating others. Feeling scared or unsafe growing up is tragic, yet as adults we are still responsible for our actions.

Reply
Maliyah keeton 3A
12/15/2025 02:51:35 pm

Absolutely not..I don’t think someone’s abusive behavior should be excused just because they were abused as a child. I do think it matters and helps explain how someone became the way they are, but explaining something is not the same as excusing it. A lot of people go through serious trauma growing up and still choose not to hurt others.

Reply
Dominguez, J 1A
12/17/2025 09:07:21 am

I agree with Maliyah , It does matter how someone grew up and if they were traumed as a kid but doesn't give you the right to treat other people wrong . Your behavior and maturity has to grow up like your age .

Reply
Elyza M. 6B
12/18/2025 10:51:01 am

I would say that they are scared and what you see as a child they do the same what they saw as child, and to be completely honest it wasn't their fault they learned that from whoever they got abused by and you learn from what you see.

Reply
Alfaro K, 1A
12/15/2025 11:06:08 pm

I don’t think their behavior is excusable, even if they were severely abused as children, because being hurt does not give someone the right to hurt others. Their past can help explain why they act the way they do, but it does not justify abusive, violent, or harmful behavior. People with cultural power especially have a responsibility to choose accountability and change instead of continuing the cycle of harm.

Reply
Taylor, M 7B
12/16/2025 12:05:15 pm

No, their behavior is not excusable. I think I'll kind of sympathize with them because nobody should have to go through that. With that being said, it still doesn't make it okay to do to someone else.

Reply
Elyza M. 6B
12/18/2025 10:54:04 am

I mean yeah but sometimes especially kids and teens repeat what's happening at home, its like bullying because the child they are going through something at home but the way to express all that sadness is bullying and ECT. I mean its not fair but they don't know how to express them-self

Reply
Thorpe, Zamyriah 7B
12/16/2025 12:19:25 pm

Although trauma often leads to cycles of violence, those later can lead to harming others, but also knowing someone's past can help us understand why they act the way they do. However the behavior is not excusable.

Reply
Gathu S, 1A
12/16/2025 06:15:12 pm

Understanding someone’s past can give context and help explain their behavior, but it doesn’t remove the harm they cause.

Reply
Gathu S, 1A
12/16/2025 06:14:04 pm

past abuse may explain why they act the way they do, but it does not excuse harming others. Understanding someone’s trauma can give context, but it doesn’t erase the responsibility they have for their actions. Accountability means facing the consequences of behavior, even if the person has been through hardship, because their choices still impact real people in real ways.

Reply
Khloe K. 5B
12/17/2025 08:45:51 am

No, their behavior isn’t excusable. Childhood abuse may explain why they act that way, but it doesn’t justify harming others. Understanding their past can foster empathy, yet accountability is still essential because power used to abuse perpetuates harm rather than healing.

Reply
Luna W. 1A
12/17/2025 09:02:55 am

Growing up with abuse or trauma is sad, but its still not an excuse to go traumatize others. It can give you reasons on why who you are today but yet again it's no excuse. Theres so many other ways to cope with things like this. Others wants you to heal not pass it on.

Reply
Dominguez , J 1A
12/17/2025 09:04:01 am

Past events are not what make you or how you are as a person , You need to be able to grow as a person and mature as an adult too be respected and want better for yourself overall

Reply
Luna W. 1A
12/17/2025 09:05:15 am

Growing up with abuse or trauma is tragic, but its still not an excuse to go traumatize others. It can give you reasons on why who you are today but yet again it's no excuse. Theres so many other ways to cope with things like this. Others wants you to heal not pass it on.

Reply
nevaeh R 5b
12/18/2025 09:14:32 am

I agree with you. Experiencing trauma can shape who someone becomes, but it doesn’t justify hurting others. Everyone has the choice to seek healing instead of passing pain forward. Accountability matters because survivors deserve safety and respect, no matter what someone has gone through in the past.

Reply
Jacobs K 7B
12/17/2025 09:51:29 am

Overall I don't believe experiencing an abusive situation is an excuse for putting someone else through that. I will say though that there are situations where someone may not realize what they're doing. Like people could have PTSD and that may cause them to have episodes where they behave a certain way and they're completely unaware of it. Or someone behaving a specific way and they may not realize it's not ok because it may be normalized to them so they see nothing wrong with it. So even though they may have a reason for their actions it still doesn't make it ok.

Reply
Parada E 2A
12/17/2025 10:33:12 am

No, their behavior is not excusable. Being hurt as a child can explain why someone struggles, but it does not give them the right to hurt others. Many people go through trauma and still choose not to be violent. If we excuse their actions, it ignores the pain of the victims and lets the harm continue. We can understand their past, but they still must take responsibility for what they do now.

Reply
Amanda Lama,5B
12/18/2025 08:42:51 am

I agree with everything you said it was very nicely explained.

Reply
Amanda Lama R, 5B
12/18/2025 08:41:25 am

Not at all. I feel like someone doing wrong is still wrong no matter who they are or what they have gone through. finding out a person was abused as a child is not an excuse for the bad stuff they have done but it is insightful to why they might be the way they are.

Reply
nevaeh R 5b
12/18/2025 09:12:07 am

Their childhood abuse may explain their behavior, but it doesn’t excuse it. Everyone is responsible for the harm they cause, and survivors deserve justice. Compassion for their past can exist, but accountability for their actions must remain.

Reply
Hurtado J 7b
12/18/2025 04:21:33 pm

Absolutely, compassion for the person is okay but its not okay for them to want others to go through the same trauma they grew up with.

Reply
Calito V. 5B
12/18/2025 09:39:59 am

I don't think it's a valid excuse to harm others because you were harmed as a child. I understand that their lives have been traumatic from someone harming them as a child but they know how it feels for life to change horribly. So why would you want to do it to someone else who knows how it feels to be violated.

Reply
Sean Patino 5B
12/18/2025 09:43:56 am

Growing up with childhood trauma is hard but just because your grow up with it doesn't mean you have to continue with it. You have to be able to grow from it as a person

Reply
Hurtado J 7b
12/18/2025 04:23:36 pm

True, you should not continue growing the trauma on someone else.

Reply
Elyza M. 6B
12/18/2025 10:45:37 am

I would say that people on social media and other people who went through trauma with another person could be scared because what if they post about the situation and people on social media could be cruel. People don't want to go to trail because they don't want to make a big deal about it and they don't want to be attacked

Reply
Hurtado J 7b
12/18/2025 04:18:56 pm

I believe childhood abuse (trauma) does not excuse abusive behavior if you know how it is to group up with that trauma why would you want to be the reason someone else now has your trauma.

Reply
Israel Hernandez
12/19/2025 11:49:39 am

I don’t think abusive behavior is excusable, even if someone went through trauma as a child. Childhood abuse can explain why a person struggles or develops harmful patterns, but it doesn’t erase the damage they cause to others.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Mixed Ink

    Mixed Ink is our class blog, the window into our souls. It was designed to improve students' writing, critical thinking and communication skills by giving them a platform to provide meaningful content based on their interpretation of what they see.

    Although the students receive a grade based on a rubric for completing this assignment, they are not graded on complexity of thought. This is a place where students of all levels can freely, confidently and creatively express themselves and their opinions in a nonjudgmental platform. They are required to respond to and critique each other, but degradation, slander, lewdness, etc., will not be tolerated. 

    Bridge Builders

    All subjects are vital to learning, but  English is the bridge of communication. So let's build the arch, one word at a time...


    Grading Rubric


    Learning Objectives
    • Communicate effectively
    • Be aware of current events
    • Write concisely
    • Boost critical thinking skills
    • Be accountable
    • Follow directions
    • Have a voice about what goes on in the world around you

    Archives

    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012


    Copyright Disclaimer
    Creative Commons License
    This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be made available by contacting [email protected].

    Categories

    All
    Class Period

    RSS Feed

©2012-2024 English Fury. All rights reserved in all media. English Fury is a registered trademark owned by thawriter.biz. No part of the contents of this website can be reproduced without the express written consent of thawriter.biz.