Church School?

11/18/2024

Angela Piazza/USA TODAY NETWORK

The Texas Education Board is to vote on Bible-infused lessons in public schools. This means that a new curriculum would focus on Christianity more than other religions. A kindergarten lesson on the Golden Rule, for example, would teach about Jesus and his Sermon on the Mount.

While some may see this as a way to instill moral values, others might argue that it risks alienating students and families who follow different faiths or no faith at all. This does raise questions about the role of religion in public education and how schools can represent diverse beliefs while remaining inclusive for all students.

Let's Write!: What do you think about a law that requires teachers teach religion?

INSTRUCTIONS

1. INCLUDE: Last Name, First Initial, AND Class Block. You do not have to include an email address or a website.

2. Respond to the post. Read the entire post, including watching any videos or reading any articles attached. Do not post vague or ambiguous commentary. Your post should have depth, be thoughtful, and provide specific, meaningful insight. Make sure it addresses the topic and encourages reflection, discussion, or a connection.

3. You MUST comment on at least TWO other posts from any student in any class. Your replies cannot be identical comments on different posts and posting shallow comments such as "I agree" or "I disagree" will earn you a zero. Make sure your reply addresses the comment that you are responding to.

4. Language. Do NOT use profanity. Vague or repeated responses will not be accepted in your post or replies.

5. Disrespectful comments will not be accepted and will result in a zero whether you do the assignment or not.

REMINDERS

**Set a weekly alarm or calendar timer. Whatever you do to remember other important events, I'd do the same for this assignment.

**Don't wait until the last minute. Telling me that you didn't do the assignment on Friday because you broke your leg, for example, on Thursday will not do anything for you when you've had a week. Be responsible and accountable.

**How to post. Click in the top right hand corner or the lower left hand corner where it says Comments to access the discussion board. Once there, scroll to the bottom of the page to post a Reply. After, choose comments from at least two students from any class and Reply to what they wrote.

CAUTION!! Do NOT embarrass me, yourself, your class, the English department, the school, your family or your upbringing with tasteless, meaningless comments. This is for a grade.

DISCLAIMER: If you do not respond AND comment on TWO others, you will not receive credit for this assignment. If you do not write your name correctly, and I don't see your work, you will not receive credit for this assignment. If you use profanity, you will not receive credit for the work. It's all or nothing.

WARNING: If you post even one second past midnight, your comment might appear to be posted, but as soon as it is opened to be graded, it will automatically delete.

Due Fri., November 22, 11:59 p.m. CST

Kendell Hurrington 4A

11/20/2024 10:54:30 am

This is unconstitutional. our country was built on religious freedom and choose. allowing a bill that imposes 1 religion over the rest is simply foolish and can only have negative repercussions. This is not about teaching children morals, as there is a plethora of normal, non-religious books and stories for kids to learn from. This is a matter of bias, of power, and of take over.

Torres C. 3/A

11/20/2024 01:59:34 pm

I would not say foolish, but more like like counterproductive, it's more of a regression as a society.

Curlee A, 4A

11/21/2024 03:17:03 pm

It is indeed a complete regression of society. We spent decades saying how religion should not rule a society because of how diverse the world is. It's ironic how we've come full circle to a society trying to return back to religion as a leader.

Espinosa M, 3A

11/20/2024 02:02:34 pm

I agree that inclusivity is essential in public education. Introducing a curriculum centered on Christianity might unintentionally marginalize students from minority religions or secular backgrounds. Schools should aim to educate about multiple religions objectively, allowing students to learn about different perspectives without promoting one over another.

Gonzalez J, 4A

11/20/2024 02:46:02 pm

"I completely agree. Introducing a single-religion curriculum risks marginalizing students from diverse backgrounds. Objective education on multiple religions promotes understanding, empathy, and informed decision-making."

Gonzalez J, 4A

11/20/2024 02:44:20 pm

"I strongly oppose this bill. Imposing one religion in public schools violates the First Amendment and undermines our nation's founding principle of religious freedom. It's unnecessary, as secular moral education exists. This is a power grab that will alienate minority faiths and non-religious students. Let's prioritize inclusivity and respect for diversity."

Hernandez M, 4A link

11/20/2024 02:47:56 pm

you are very correct there's other ways to teach kids morals and lessons without the implementation of religion and it would violate the first amendment right.

jahlil .H 4A

11/20/2024 03:20:34 pm

I also agree that this is foolish because everybody grew up and was taught
different religion

Divine Ojeh 8B

11/21/2024 09:37:30 am

I agree, public schools should not teach students about religion. But if they were to required too, I'll rather have a professional teacher to teach about every religion and not one religion.

Bronson M, 3A

11/21/2024 09:03:13 am

I agree, our country was built on religious freedom and beliefs. Allowing the pass of a bill that failed to agree with our first amendment is wrong. This is a matter of power and take over to force kids to believe in a certain thing.

Nathan Torres

11/21/2024 01:59:33 pm

I agree with Kendell mainly since its true one is born with the right to choose your own religion. It is stated in the first amendment where one has the freedom to choose their religion.

Gonzalez D. 8B

11/22/2024 01:51:50 pm

I agree with this because choosing one religion over the rest is unfair for the students since they are not given options to other religions they might believe in.

espinosa M, 3A

11/20/2024 02:01:45 pm

The proposed curriculum change requiring Bible-infused lessons in Texas public schools raises significant concerns about inclusivity and the separation of church and state. While the intent to instill moral values may be commendable, public schools serve students from diverse religious and cultural backgrounds. By focusing solely on Christianity, the curriculum risks alienating students who practice other faiths or those who identify as non-religious. Public education should remain neutral in matters of religion, fostering an environment where all students feel respected and included. Instead, schools could teach moral values through universally accepted principles that do not tie to a specific religion.

Torres C. 3/A

11/20/2024 02:02:51 pm

It should be neutral, we as students should be given free will to choose what we want to follow

Divine Ojeh 8B

11/21/2024 09:38:53 am

I agree, we should not force religion on students but it will be nice if somebody talks to student about religion/not forcing it, so they could encourage somebody.

Grant Z 4A

11/21/2024 12:37:03 pm

I agree, forcing a belief on someone can do the opposite of people might be thinking.

Knowles K 1A

12/13/2024 11:14:04 pm

Agree parents should have a option whether they want their kids to learn about religion or not you can’t force someone to do something they are not comfortable doing

Hernandez M, 4A link

11/20/2024 02:45:56 pm

I agree with everything said here it would be problematic to not leave the religion and beliefs up to the kids an what they believe in and pretty sure it would be violating the first amendment right of freedom of religion.

Colocho J 6B

11/21/2024 03:44:47 pm

I agree because each level taught I mean people are going to learn from it and achieve to over come it.

Malvaez M 1A

11/22/2024 01:30:33 pm

Public Education should only focus on teaching the right subjects, teaching a religious goes beyond the points morals and people should see that religion and education are two different things and religion is something that should be chosen to be followed by people who wish to want to believe in religion and being forced to believe in something you just don;t see in is unjustifiabale

Presas A 6B

11/24/2024 10:42:44 am

In this perspective that you reasoning with and applying to that public schools should remain neutral in matter of religion to ensure incivility you make an important point about how focusing solely on Christianity might alienate students of other faiths or those who are non religious. while moral values are essential teaching them though a secular framework could foster unity without favoring one group over another.However do you think there's a way to incorporate lessons about multiple religious in a comparative and educational way to promote understanding and respect for diversity.

Torres. C 3/A

11/20/2024 02:04:41 pm

It's not right for schools to mandate religion in school. It defys everything American "stands for" which is freedom of religion, speech, and of course persuit of happiness.

espinosa m, 3a

11/20/2024 02:05:45 pm

While I understand the intention behind promoting moral values, I believe there are ways to do this without making religion a focal point in public schools. For instance, lessons on ethics and social responsibility can be taught using secular examples that resonate with everyone, regardless of their religious beliefs

Kendell Hurrington 4A

11/20/2024 02:49:08 pm

This is exactly what I thought. There are a multitude of avenues schools can take to teach kids about morals and life lessons. The bill makers trying to use that as an excuse or validation only makes them seem like they lack forethought.

Grant Z 4A

11/22/2024 01:01:32 pm

I agree, I feel that shouldn't even be our main topic in public shcool unless it was about all religions and not just one. Also like you said the're many ways to instill certain qualities.

Sanchez A 3A

11/20/2024 03:23:39 pm

I agree it does defy what America stands for with the freedom of religion, speech and pursuit of happiness. This law shouldn't be mandated in schools.

jahlil .H 4A

11/20/2024 03:58:39 pm

I agree because it won't be fair to everyone else and it will cause chaos

Varela, L 8B

11/21/2024 01:39:35 pm

I agree with this, the bill of rights gave us our form of freedom and this would violate the first amendment.

Esquivel. E 1A

11/22/2024 08:54:33 am

It's pretty contradicting all that America stands for, it was originally founded on Christianity. If it was founded on Christianity shouldn't have Gods law been taught to us way earlier?

Sanchez A 3A

11/20/2024 02:06:42 pm

This law should not be allowed into schools, it goes against the bill of rights that should never be changed by any law or rule. Everyone in U.S should already be against this and should never question if they should enforce a religion this is not the Aztecs and mayas.

Teniente J. 1A

11/20/2024 03:33:23 pm

I agree that the schools are not allow to change a person mindset or beliefs where they force it onto them. Everyone wants to practice there own religion where they are free to do what they want, as the US is to be known as a free state.

Grant Z 4A

11/21/2024 12:35:36 pm

I feel that eryone has the right to believe in what they want, religion shouldn't be forced onto someone. I do think it's good however not all teachers belive in that so it would be going aginst what they believe. I don't think it's fair to those who grew up beliving in one thing to have to be forced to learn or follow.

Lara, S 8B

11/21/2024 03:09:55 pm

Schools should not be allowed to teach kids what they should believe in nothing should change that. The choice of religion should be each person's decision.

Curlee A, 4A

11/21/2024 03:10:56 pm

Completely agree, we are in the modern age. Long are the days where we as a country want one religion to dictate the life of everyone. The right to religious beliefs should not me we force those beliefs on the population.

Garcia M 3A

11/22/2024 08:51:49 am

I agree, Students shouldn't be forced to be given information about something they don't have interest in, yes I believe students should look towards God but if they want to learn or know about the bible and Christianity they will find their way towards it on their own, religion should never be forced .

Fuentez M 3A

11/22/2024 11:57:55 pm

I agree completely what you say. As a Christian I found my own path I looked for my own journey and belive in what I believe in without anyone’s help. If the government barely wants us to talk about black culture, and Hispanic culture, and talk about slavery. Then they should not even bring up about religion. If they want to take away certain books that talks about culture and community. Then they shouldn’t be allowed to teach about religion. You can’t force someone to do what they want. We have rights for a reason to not be in a communism country.

Cavazos N 6B

11/22/2024 10:43:31 pm

I agree that everyone in the U.S should be against this law because it breaks the 1st Amendment.

Gonzalez J, 4A

11/20/2024 02:40:29 pm

"I think incorporating Bible-infused lessons can provide valuable cultural context and moral guidance. However, it's crucial to ensure balance and representation of diverse faiths. Let's implement this curriculum thoughtfully, prioritizing inclusivity and respect for all students."

Alvarez J 8B

11/21/2024 02:15:06 pm

I don't believe that they could find a balance. Its highly complicated to not exploit the law, causing schools to not include other cultural backgrounds.

Hernandez M, 4A link

11/20/2024 02:41:54 pm

I feel that as a Christian I'd want everyone to know about Jesus and what he did for us and the world but I also think that teaching only Christianity in school would be problematic in a bunch of ways and that its best to keep religion out of school. For example if someone wanted to go to a school in the middle east and they only taught Islam in school and I'm a Christian in that school id feel pretty bad that they didn't leave it up to the students if they wanna learn or not

Kendell Hurrington 4A

11/20/2024 02:46:48 pm

This is very mature and an agreeable stance> its not fair to those who practice different faiths to be forced to learn just one. Weather we like it or not, schools should be impartial and teach the base and facts when it comes to education and real world matters.

Tobias A, 3A

11/20/2024 07:12:49 pm

I agree having one religion being taught in schools will lead to issues, becuase if you are a Christian being taught in a different school religion it wouldn't feel right. I believe its best if students choose what they want to learn about.

Dralyn S. 4A

11/20/2024 02:44:41 pm

The key would be ensuring that any teaching about religion in schools is balance, respectful, and focused on fostering critical thinking rather than promoting particular religious doctrines.

Barrientos S 4A

11/20/2024 02:50:34 pm

Speaking on religion during school can be a risky topic to speak on, similar to politics. Simply because it is inappropriate, religion is not something bad to speak on but during school it just isn't the right place to teach.

jahlil .H 4A

11/20/2024 02:56:05 pm

I think this law should not be allowed because 1 there is no point of teaching religion when it already churches every were and there would be no reason for this law because people would be already be arguing beacause some people they wouldn't believe in what other people do and everybody gots there own opion and everyone was raised or taught to believe in deffert

Teniente J. 1A

11/20/2024 03:37:54 pm

I agree that they even thought about forcing schools to focus on 1 religion where majority schools are very diverse in color, and beliefs and creating this will just make everyone feel separated and create conflict among students. They shouldn't make this law happen so they can avoid fights.

Tobias A, 3A

11/20/2024 07:22:17 pm

I agree we do have churches so why teach religion in school. People will have their own opinions and some wont like the way they think so it causes more issues, so I basically think we shouldn't get this law.

Hayes T 8B

11/21/2024 03:30:18 pm

I feel the same way they shouldn't add religion as a class if people want to learn about Christianity they should go to church or they should attend in a christian school where they can learn about religion.

Colocho J 6B

11/21/2024 03:43:50 pm

I agree because different people have different mind sets.

Lopez M 1A

11/22/2024 08:36:09 am

There is honestly no reason why schools would even teach religion since churches already have classes to learn more about their religion. I fear this law would also foster unnecessary hate towards individuals and the outcome of this possible situation is not going to be good.

Cavazos N 6B

11/22/2024 10:34:12 pm

I agree, if a parent wants to teach their children about religion they should take them to one out of the 300,000 churches in the U.S.

Teniente J. 1A

11/20/2024 03:30:21 pm

The new law is very unconstitutional that goes against the first amendment, and schools aren't allowed to change a student religion without consent which will cause many controversy among the school.There is places where students can go practice there religion with there parents, and school is only for teaching education to help students not change who they are entirely. Every school should respect the student and parent boundaries and respect what they want to teach there kid.

Hurd j

11/20/2024 03:53:50 pm

I agree because school is a place of learning not church

Lara, S 8B

11/21/2024 02:57:11 pm

School should not be teaching religion, school was created to help educate individuals learn more on subjects that will help you in a persons career and future. They should have no say in what a person think or believes in. Every individual is different and school cannot expect to change one's beliefs by forcing individuals to believe in one religion.

Hurd j

11/20/2024 03:52:01 pm

the new law is very discouraging and it goes against the first amendment and schools are not allowed to change the student religion or affend it school s a place to learn not a place of religion or church

Tobias A, 3A

11/20/2024 07:26:46 pm

The law isn't something we need because why would they want people to learn about religion in school when we already have churches around. Its best to leave it to them and only teaching 1 religion can cause people issues meaning they wont always agree on your own personal opinion or support what you believe. Plus school isn't the best place to teach about it.

Sanchez A 3A

11/21/2024 03:03:54 pm

I agree if they want people to learn about religion they should go to church and not force it in school. Also students want to learn about religion that won't help them to succeed in the future.

Gonzalez D, 8B

11/22/2024 01:55:45 pm

I agree, I think the students should find their religion on their own outside of school and with nobody whispering in their ear or forcing a certain religion on to them.

Williams Jamari 6B

11/20/2024 08:05:51 pm

Bronson M, 3A

11/21/2024 08:56:35 am

I agree, the new law goes against the first amendment which is our freedom of religion. Only teaching one religion is forcing students to believe more in that than the one they actually believe in. There are churches for different religions for peoples beliefs. School should only be for students education not changing their beliefs.

Fuentez M 3a

11/22/2024 11:55:10 pm

Agreeing with what you say and to add on . A case similar took place in 1962. The case was called Eangle V Vitale . This was an event that took place because kids were forced to say prayers at school. Which was a violation of the 1st amendment. Looking at this , teaching religion in school is a Violation of the 1st amendment.

Bronson M, 3A

11/21/2024 08:51:49 am

I teachers should not have to teach religion because there are many students who have different religions or just don't believe in anything. We are supposed to have freedom of religion and if they start teaching Christianity they are forcing kids to go against their beliefs and rights. The schools should not try to change students beliefs or teach one religion because they have the right to believe in what they want.

Guzman X.6B

11/21/2024 09:14:16 pm

I agree that teachers should not be forced to teach religion, especially when students have different beliefs. Everyone has the right to choose their own religion or have no religion at all. Teaching one religion in schools could pressure students to go against their beliefs. Schools should respect all students' right to believe what they want.

Alarcon A, 3A

11/22/2024 08:41:03 am

I agree teachers should not teach religion to students because the first amendment insists on freedom of speech and religion in which we choose what we believe in and cannot be forced upon us.

Divine Ojeh 8B

11/21/2024 09:35:35 am

Requiring teachers teachers to teach religion in public schools is a disagreement. Learning about religion can encourage someone to have a good lifestyle, but focusing on one religion violates the students on their different beliefs, they have to teach them every religion equally.

Varela, L 8B

11/21/2024 01:33:31 pm

Having this law that will make teachers have more bible-infused lessons could cause anger in parents that have a different religion. Everyone's allowed to have their own religions and beliefs, it would not be fair to put one religion over another. Overall, religion should be an untouched subject in school, it would be in violation of the first amendment allowing people to have freedom of religion.

Nathan Torres 3A

11/21/2024 01:57:19 pm

I think that this is against the law not only because they will be forcing a specific religion into them which is christianity, but also because it will be taking away someones rights. People are born with rights and one of them is being able to choose your own religion and have your own beliefs. Adding a lesson about religion will also be something that would require which will mean taking away time to learn something useful.

Guzman X. 6B

11/21/2024 09:11:31 pm

I agree that forcing one religion on students takes away their freedom to choose their beliefs. Schools should focus on teaching useful subjects, not religion. Everyone should be free to follow their own beliefs without pressure. Religious lessons could take away valuable learning time.

Alvarez J 8B

11/21/2024 02:08:06 pm

If I recall correctly there is supposed to be a separation of church from the state that is important to democracy. I believe that including religion in an educational setting is highly inappropriate because everyone has different beliefs and including only Christianity is wrong. The 1st amendment is freedom of speech, and I think that teaching religion would be oppressing in a way to children with different backgrounds and different religious believes.

Vega F 1A

11/21/2024 08:47:29 pm

I agree with you, everyone has different beliefs and that’s why we have the first amendment and this should be respected.

Stevenson J 8B link

12/18/2024 03:05:51 pm

I agreeFirst Amendment: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Malvaez M 1A

11/22/2024 01:26:49 pm

Peoples freedoms are being violated, teaching a student can indeed oppress many of their religious believes in a negative aspect.

Lara, S 8B

11/21/2024 02:50:30 pm

I think the law is going against the freedom of people. The first amendment is supposed to give the people freedom, the "freedom" of speech is already limited and now they want to limit the freedom of religion.I do not think it is right to forced the practice of religion on people who can not decide for themselves and for older people they should be freedom to practice whatever region they choice. Even the teachers are affected by this law because even if it is against their religion,if they want to keep their job, they have to teach it. The decision of religion should be every person's choice, it is unfair to every person who believes different from what the school teaches.

Lopez M 1A

11/22/2024 08:30:31 am

Yes the choice should be one's to make. I also think it's not right to force religion down on others because everyone should have a choice whether they want to be religious or not. In recent years the government has restricted our freedom of speech and now our freedom of religion. Ultimately it is up to us to come together and do something to stop this or at least let our voices be heard.

Presas A 6B

11/24/2024 10:52:57 am

You make a strong point about the importance of freedom and how this law could infringe on individual rights protected by the First Amendment. I agree that the religion is a deeply personal decision and should never be forced on anyone especially in public schools where students and teachers come from diverse backgrounds. Forcing teachers to go against their beliefs to keep their jobs is also a serious concern and could create unnecessary conflict. I also wonder how this law would handle teaching about other religious or the choice not to follow any religion. Do you think there's a way to teach about religion in schools objectively like as part of history or cultural studies without it being seen as forcing beliefs on others.

Curlee A, 4A

11/21/2024 03:00:01 pm

As someone who is religious, I do believe that religion is very important to my well being as a person. Although I would wish for more encouragement of religious beliefs in school systems, forcing this natural process of religion just feels wrong. Religion is not a universal concept, some people aren't even religious. To force such a concept on everyone is down right immoral, people have the right to believe in whatever they want to believe.

Hayes T 8B

11/21/2024 03:25:17 pm

I agree with you I don't think religion should be forced on a person they should be willing to want to learn it by themselves.

Vega F 1A

11/21/2024 08:46:09 pm

I agree with you forcing religion on kids feels wrong and people do have the right to believe in whatever they want.

Castillo, V 6B

11/22/2024 06:38:56 pm

I agree, everyone does have a right to believe what they want but maybe having that can change their mindset a bit but at the end of the day it’s their decision to believe what they want.

Victorino H 8B

11/22/2024 11:38:18 pm

I agree with you as forcing a child to learn is immoral especially if they are being taught differently at home.

Miles D 4A

11/22/2024 11:48:29 pm

I agree with you because forcing somebody to learn something they have no intrest in is not only not moraly right but almost cult like and that's something that shouldn't be in a school setting.

Hayes T 8B

11/21/2024 03:22:38 pm

I agree I feel like schools shouldn't force people to learn about Christianity they should have the freedom to speak up and they also shouldn't just teach one religion when other people don't believe in Christianity.

Colocho J 6B

11/21/2024 03:42:48 pm

I think that people have different perspectives and need to rely on what benefits students the most. If it's the person's decision then yeah, but realize it's the kids if they want to or need it.

Garcia M 3A

11/22/2024 08:47:59 am

I agree, I'm Christian but I feel like students shouldn't be forced to believe or learn something that they don't want to.

Rodriguez R. 4A

11/22/2024 02:57:04 pm

I agree, it should be up to the students to decide for themselves.

Vega F 1A

11/21/2024 08:45:00 pm

This law goes against our freedom of religion because schools will force children to learn a religion when they could have different beliefs, and this can make them think that this is the only right choice. Schools should not decide what religion we should be taught and should focus just on teaching.

Alarcon A 3A

11/22/2024 08:46:57 am

I agree, we shouldn't be forced into following another religion we originally didn't believe in because yes it does go against our freedom of religion.

Esquivel. E 1A

11/22/2024 08:50:06 am

I don't think its about religion, its like teaching history from way way back to the original law.

Guzman X. 6B

11/21/2024 09:09:31 pm

A law that requires teaching religion in schools could cause problems. Focusing on one religion, like Christianity, might leave out students from other religions or no religion. Schools should respect all students and include everyone. Moral lessons can be taught without focusing on just one religion. If religion is taught, it should be fair to all beliefs.

Anukem Emmanuel, 1A

11/22/2024 11:05:59 am

I absolutely agree, teaching morals without focusing on one particular religion is a lot healthy and comfortable, then teaching one particular religion.

Echeverria D 6B

11/22/2024 12:04:35 pm

Requiring teachers of different faiths to teach a curriculum they do not agree with could also create discomfort and ethical dilemmas. It highlights the challenge of maintaining an inclusive and respectful educational environment for all students and educators.

Salgado M, 1A

11/22/2024 02:31:17 pm

I agree. It doesn't take religion to instill morals into a person. It's possible for kids to just learn what's good and what's bad from being tol and being shown examples. They don't need a series of beliefs in a divine power in order to be good people.

Rodriguez R. 4A

11/22/2024 02:55:30 pm

I agree, there are other places to teach and learn about religion, having it being taught in schools will be leaving out those students with no religion.

Lopez M 1A

11/22/2024 08:22:00 am

This new law will bring society back several years because escaping religious persecution was one of the main reasons america was form. The first amendment states that we have freedom to religion and by putting the new law in place it will completely contradict the first amendment. Teachers that believe in a different religion will have to teach the new curriculum even though they do not want to. Which goes to show that the line between the church and state has been completely blurred.

Garcia M 3A

11/22/2024 08:38:47 am

This decision raises questions about inclusivity and the representation of diverse beliefs in public education. The concern is about alienating students from different faiths or those with no religious affiliation .

Alarcon A 3A

11/22/2024 08:44:02 am

Teachers should not teach religion because not everyone is going to believe in the same thing and this could go against the freedom of religion in which people can live by their own religious traditions. Teaching religion can force us into living by someone else's traditions.

Flores F, 4A

11/22/2024 11:18:04 am

agreed, we shouldn't force people to live with a tradition that they don't agree with or believe in

Esquivel. E 1A

11/22/2024 08:48:03 am

A law that requires teachers to teach religion is very good. I would prefer children to be taught about the love of God in the Bible than not be taught good moral in general. It truly depends on how public education decides to go about this that can make it positive or negative.

Anukem Emmanuel, 1A

11/22/2024 10:54:59 am

I agree with the idea that teachers should teach "good" morals, however I don't believe that religion, specifically Christianity as the basis of that as it violates not only the freedom of religion but could make people who don't agree with that religion uncomfortable.

Echeverria D 6B

11/22/2024 12:03:45 pm

I think Teaching "good" morals is indeed important, but it should be done in a way that respects the diverse beliefs and backgrounds of all students

Aiyanyo E 3A

11/24/2024 11:41:41 pm

I agree, there’s nothing wrong with teaching valuable lessons to children. However using religious tools like the bible to teach children in a public school is a clear violation of the 1st amendment.

Rodriguez Y. 3B

11/22/2024 03:09:04 pm

Religion shouldn't be banned from teaching I just feel as though they shouldn't focus on a certain religion. Schools should focus on education and teaching students more about reading, writing, math science, and other important subjects.

Castillo, V 6B

11/22/2024 06:34:58 pm

Yess I agree but they can also focus on both things.

Salgado M, 1A

11/22/2024 09:11:57 am

It's one thing to teach about certain religions and their histories, but making teachers preach any religion to students is a very clear violation of one of the liberties that the first amendment protects: freedom of religion. America today is and should be a country where anyone can practice any religion they want to, and that's if they even want to follow one in the first place. I've been taught about the worlds religions before and they were all taught in a non bias way by teachers who may have followed different religions or not any at all, and they never preached to me or to follow a certain religion. I do believe that the history of religions should be taught, especially since out of the 8 billion people in the world, over 6 billion of them follow either Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, etc. All of those religions differ greatly from each other, and their role to the lives over the majority of the worlds people, So teaching of religions is a needed thing, but trying to make children follow a certain religion is immoral and can bother kids depending on what religion they follow. Kids should learn about how different people could be from them, but not indoctrinated to try and be one of them. Separate church from state.

Flores A, 4A

11/22/2024 11:09:38 am

I fully agree with there should be a separation between education and religion, along with the history of said religions history should be taught to lead a better understanding of the world

Stevenson J 8B link

12/18/2024 03:03:34 pm

I agree some people may not believe in the same thing as other which will cause a problem at school for the students and the teachers.

Anukem Emmanuel, 1A

11/22/2024 10:49:52 am

The idea that Teachers should teach Christianity in public schools is a clear violation of the first amendment: The freedom of religion. This isn't really suprising as the entire Texan government is specifically republican.

Salgado M, 1A

11/22/2024 02:25:45 pm

I agree, a lot of the republican politicians in power that want such a law never take into account that many people don't follow the same religion as them.

Rodriguez Y. 3B

11/22/2024 02:47:17 pm

Christianity is not something that schools should talk about. Schools should focus on increasing students daily learning and educating them to not repeat the same American mistakes that have been committed before.

Flores A, 4A

11/22/2024 10:53:12 am

This could be a massive problem since there should be a clear divide between normal education and religious education since a lot of people come from different religions backgrounds, I think there should be like an optional class for religious studies that are optional and can be taken for students that are interested.

Thompson D 8B

11/22/2024 10:26:55 pm

I agree with you. There should be a clear divide between regular education and religious education to respect the diverse backgrounds of students. An optional class for religious studies would be a great solution, allowing students to learn about different religions if they're interested, without imposing any specific belief on everyone. This way, schools can remain inclusive and focused on academic learning, while still providing opportunities for those who want to explore religious topics.

Echeverria D 6B

11/22/2024 12:02:52 pm

Implementing Bible-infused lessons in public schools raises important questions about the balance between educational content and religious inclusivity.

Malvaez M 1A

11/22/2024 01:24:34 pm

Everyone is entitled to believe whatever religion they choose, being forced to believe in one one religion goes against peoples freedom rights. Many people come from a history of only one belief and having teachers teach one religion can affect not only a students mind but can also affect the students family members by causing concern for their children and decide what they should do to address this matter of forced religion beleif.

Gonzalez S 4A link

11/22/2024 09:56:55 pm

Yes this could cause such big problems to the schools and families. Your statement explained the depths of how the situation could cause major problems.

Gonzalez D 8B

11/22/2024 01:47:57 pm

Its unconstitutional, we are given the right to choose our own religion implementing this law takes away that right away from us in a way. You'd be forcing the religion on to the kids instead of letting them find their own religion,

Lopez H 4A

11/22/2024 10:17:31 pm

Exactly! there are children that don't believe in their religion and may feel that theirs isn't normal or accepted.

Rodriguez Y. 3B

11/22/2024 02:13:35 pm

What do you think about a law that requires teachers teach religion?The Law that requires teachers to teach religion is very biased and unacceptable specially since the law inquires to only teach Christianity. Schools should be about teaching students about different kind of educational concepts, different historical events so we wont repeat them and lessons on life and they should help build our future. Religion is something that should taught but every other religion should be introduced not just one.

Galvez J, 3A

11/22/2024 02:14:46 pm

It shouldn't be forced onto people who do not believe in religion or believe in another religion. Although if a student one day wants to learn about this then it should be an option in middle or high school. It's not a bad idea for people who do want to talk about the religion they believe in to have that option to do it.

Lopez H 4A

11/22/2024 10:16:14 pm

I agree, religion can be taught at someones own interest, but it should not be forced, especially if not everyone believes in a god or in their god.

Rodriguez R. 4A

11/22/2024 02:49:04 pm

I think the law that requires teachers to teach religion should be optional and not required for all. This would discourage others into thinking they have no choice in believing or not in religions. But then there are also others who would want to learn more about their religion they believe in.

Gonzalez S 4A link

11/22/2024 10:00:48 pm

I agree some students will find the class great but for others there's no benefit for it. They could add a class that isn't required but is there for students that wanna learn about their religion more.

Castillo, V 6B

11/22/2024 06:34:12 pm

If their was a law where teacher taught religion I feel like it wouldn’t make such a difference since everyone has there own beliefs but it could helps others learn about how important religion could be.

Gonzalez S 4A link

11/22/2024 09:53:03 pm

I believe religion shouldn't be taught or talked about in school teachings due to different students having different beliefs. It's inappropriate and disgusting to force a religion onto someone especially children.

Lopez H 4A

11/22/2024 10:14:57 pm

Many people don't realize that not everyone prays to the same god or to a god in general. Schools are meant to be a neutral place, and this makes me believe that in the future children will feel pressured or influenced in having other ways of thinking. People will think that their religion doesn't matter or that it is not relevant. Religion has no place in school and should be kept away from it. Let the parents teach their kids about THEIR religion.

Thompson D 8b

11/22/2024 10:26:16 pm

I agree that schools should stay neutral on religion. They should be inclusive for all students, and introducing a specific religion could make some feel pressured or excluded. Parents should teach their children about their faith at home, while schools focus on providing an education that respects all beliefs.

Soto, A 1A

11/22/2024 10:55:42 pm

I agree, religion being taught in schools is not needed and could cause problems regarding the kids parents.

Cavazos N 6B

11/22/2024 10:22:15 pm

Religion being taught in schools because it is unconstitutional and teaching religion in schools can cause more harm than good. Many people have different beliefs and if you were to teach only one religion it can make those who don't have the same beliefs feel like their beliefs don't matter.

Aiyanyo E 3A

11/24/2024 11:38:50 pm

I agree with this because as the 1st amendment states, we have to keep church and state separate. What this school is doing is unconstitutional and doesn’t realize that every child doesn’t believe in the Christian faith.

Thompson D 8B

11/22/2024 10:25:28 pm

A law requiring teachers to teach religion in public schools raises concerns about inclusivity. While teaching about religion can help students understand history and culture, focusing too heavily on one religion, like Christianity, may alienate students from different faiths or no faith at all. Public schools should remain neutral and inclusive, offering a balanced approach that respects diverse beliefs. Ideally, the curriculum should teach about various religions to foster understanding without promoting one over others. The goal is to ensure education is respectful and equitable for all students.

Soto, A 1A

11/22/2024 10:54:16 pm

I agree, everyone has their own beliefs and schools should not try to teach something different to others.

Victorino H 8B

11/22/2024 11:39:53 pm

I agree as more than likely school will teach Christianity only and not focus to much on other religions and cause the alienation of students who believe in other religions.

Miles D 4A

11/22/2024 11:45:06 pm

I agree schools should stay more nuetral and keep religion out of school not only for people who may be feel alienated but for those who just want no part in religion at all.

Soto, A 1A

11/22/2024 10:53:27 pm

I don't think that religion in schools is bad, but I do not think that religion should be taught at public schools because not everyone may believe in Christianity. Some people may not agree with their beliefs which could cause conflict with parents, parents could just choose a private religion school.

Victorino H 8B

11/22/2024 11:37:01 pm

A law that requires teachers to start teaching religion shouldn't be passed because many children learn religion in their homes and more than likely the school will focus on mainly one religion excluding children and making them feel left out, i also believe that children don't need to learn this as it is not a vital subject that need to be taught and learned.

Miles D 4A

11/22/2024 11:43:25 pm

I think the law that forces teachers to teach religion is rediculous. Religion shouldn't be forced onto people who have want to learn about religion or be apart of any religous groups. Religion has no place in school it should be it's own thing outside of shcool and nobody should be forced to have to learn a religion they want no part in.

Fuentez M 3A

11/22/2024 11:50:33 pm

As a Christian myself and a person who goes out and preach. What we do is try to teach people about God but if they don’t want to hear then they don’t want to. We don’t force anyone if they say they are Catholic or atheist or muslin. We don’t go off and try to change their perspective if that’s what they want that’s what they wants teachers teaching about religion mainly Christianity is not okay because others have different beliefs and thoughts . It’s okay to me to be open about my religion but I won’t make my boyfriend who is Catholic by force learn my teachings. If he wants to he wants to and if he doesn’t he doesn’t . Teachers shouldn’t teach religion their main job is to teach students how to prepare for college. In college they most definitely will not talk about religion unless you are in a Bible study or a Bible major. Every teacher will not teach you and force to teach you a religion. All they care about is you turning in your work and that’s what highschool teach us is responsibility and what to expect in college not religion.

Presas A 6B

11/24/2024 10:34:17 am

The debate over weather teachers should be required to tech religion in public schools is a complex and sensitive issue. On one had, proponents argue that teaching about religion can promote moral values and cultural understanding. On the other hand opponents raise concerns about incivility and the potential alienation of students from diverse backgrounds.This essay will explore both sides of the argument and ultimately advocate for a balanced approach to teaching religion in schools.

Aiyanyo E 3A

11/24/2024 11:35:25 pm

As the first amendment of the constitution states, church and state must be separate and that goes for our education system. The reason it should be like that since we can’t teach children to not think for themselves and force them into a religion. There is nothing wrong with teaching Christianity, however it doesn’t belong in the Texas Education System.

Hernandez, I 6b

12/2/2024 10:43:22 am

agreed there is a reason why they are separte

Hernandez, I 6b

12/2/2024 10:40:48 am

I think its stupid that they have to teach religion because what if the students don't want to learn it or don't care about it or just dont believe in that stuff and dont want it shoved down their throat. same with the teachers what if they dont personally believe in the stuff either.

Knowles K 1A

12/13/2024 11:18:06 pm

Parents should have the option into whether they want their kids learning about that religion or not if you try teaching them about that said religion and they parents don’t agree that can cause havoc.

Stevenson J 8B link

12/18/2024 03:01:34 pm

It could be a good thing to teach kids about our Lord and savior. ButTeaching students about religion in an objective, balanced and factual manner has been incorporated into California's History–Social Science (HSS) Content Standards since 1998, and is also part of the new HSS Framework, points out Juliana Liebke, a social studies curriculum specialist for San Diego Unified School

Comments are closed.

Mixed Ink

Mixed Ink is our class blog, the window into our souls. It was designed to improve students' writing, critical thinking and communication skills by giving them a platform to provide meaningful content based on their interpretation of what they see.

Although the students receive a grade based on a rubric for completing this assignment, they are not graded on complexity of thought. This is a place where students of all levels can freely, confidently and creatively express themselves and their opinions in a nonjudgmental platform. They are required to respond to and critique each other, but degradation, slander, lewdness, etc., will not be tolerated.

Bridge Builders

All subjects are vital to learning, but English is the bridge of communication. So let's build the arch, one word at a time...

Grading Rubric

Learning Objectives

Communicate effectively
Be aware of current events
Write concisely
Boost critical thinking skills
Be accountable
Follow directions
Have a voice about what goes on in the world around you

Church School?

Mixed Ink

Bridge Builders

Grading Rubric

Archives

Categories